Featured Editorials
-
Scottsdale’s Hospitals Prove Their National Standing Once Again
Scottsdale has long punched above its weight in health care, and the newest U.S. News Best Hospitals rankings confirm it again. HonorHealth Scottsdale Shea Medical Center once more lands among Arizona’s top-recognized hospitals, a distinction it has now earned across multiple ranking cycles. T...Read more
-
Supervisor Galvin’s Statement on the Passing of U.S. Senator Jon Kyl
“I am deeply saddened by the passing of former U.S. Senator Jon Kyl, not only for the loss of this great man, but for what his passing represents to all Arizonans. Senator Kyl was a statesman in every sense of the word. He was staunch in his beliefs, yet always sought compromise. Senator Kyl w...Read more
-
Guest Editorial: Can We Follow the Plan?
By Councilwoman Solange Whitehead Should Scottsdale Residents Pay Double for Water? The current Council majority has gone to great lengths—and at ratepayers’ expense—to work around Scottsdale’s Water Strategic Plan, an adopted plan designed to keep our water flowing, safe, and affordable. The latest...Read more
Marketplace
-
Scottsdale Art Week Presented by Scottsdale Ferrari Announces Dates and Ticket Sales for Third Edition of Largest New American Art Fair in Decades
International Art and Design Fair With 110 Galleries to Take Place During High Season of Fastest-Growing Millionaire Community in Country More than 21,000 guests and a 133% jump in ticket sales made the Second Edition of Scottsdale Art Week Presented by Scottsdale Ferrari one to celebrate. Now, tick...Read more
-
The Phoenix Symphony’s 2026/27 Season to Feature Music of Taylor Swift, John Williams, Fleetwood Mac, Blockbuster Films and More
PHOENIX (September 11, 2026) – The Phoenix Symphony announces that single tickets are on sale for its 2026/27 Season, the organization’s 79th anniversary season, featuring an exciting new chapter in the Symphony’s history with newly appointed Virginia G. Piper Music Director Designate Paolo Bortolam...Read more
-
Fennemore and Gallagher & Kennedy to Combine, Creating One of Arizona’s Largest Business Law Firms
Fennemore and Gallagher & Kennedy (G&K) will join forces Dec. 1, 2026. This landmark law firm combination will provide clients across Arizona and New Mexico access to a broader bench of lawyers and legal services, including Fennemore’s proprietary technology and innovation platforms through ...Read more
Scrum
-
Op-Ed: Why do Zubia’s Allies Avoid the Issues?
By Ignacio del Valle, Scottsdale resident The opinion pages have been busy this election — and the pattern is impossible to ignore. Residents who support Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita — or the many who have doubts about Raoul Zubia — are focusing on the issues: the connection between high-de...Read more
-
Op-Ed: Barry Graham Endorses Election Deniers. Nobody Has Held Him Accountable
By John Ainley Harry Dunn, a former U.S. Capitol police officer who was beaten by January 6th insurrectionists, will be in Maricopa County later this week. This reminded me of Barry Graham’s endorsement of Alexander Kolodin for Arizona Secretary of State. Kolodin was directly involved in efforts cha...Read more
-
Op-Ed: Raoul Zubia is Mainstream and Has the Moral High Ground
By Jim Derouin Jerome Garcia’s recent post makes several claims about Raoul Zubia that are preposterous and simply not true. Most glaring is the assertion that Raoul’s support comes “exclusively from Democrats and socialist factions.” That is pure poppy cock. Raoul’s publicly listed endorsers inclu...Read more
Marketplace

International Art and Design Fair With 110 Galleries to Take Place During High Season of Fastest-Growing Millionaire Community in Country

More than 21,000 guests and a 133% jump in ticket sales made the Second Edition of Scottsdale Art Week Presented by Scottsdale Ferrari one to celebrate. Now, tickets are on sale for the Third Edition of the international art and design fair set for March 18 – 21, 2027, at WestWorld of Scottsdale.
The four-day fair will again bring galleries and collectors from around the globe to Scottsdale, filling WestWorld’s famous North Hall with thousands of works spanning blue-chip, contemporary, modern, Indigenous, Western and international art.
“Last year’s fair affirmed that collectors are not simply discovering Scottsdale Art Week—they are returning, participating and increasingly making it part of their annual calendar,” said Fair Director Amy Gause. “From the outset, our ambition has been to establish an international art fair that gives collectors a compelling reason to experience the Southwest through the lens of art and culture. Scottsdale provides an extraordinary setting for that vision, particularly during a season when the region’s finest resorts are at their height and Major League Baseball brings remarkable energy to the Valley. We have established something with real staying power—a fair that is building a broader collector community, attracting an increasingly distinguished international gallery roster and claiming a lasting place for Scottsdale on the global art calendar.”
The Third Edition will feature gallery presentations alongside monumental works and installations, as well as a
full slate of cultural programming with artists and leading voices from across the art world. Scottsdale Art Week will announce additional participating galleries, artists and programming in the coming months.
The fair will again open with a First Look from 2 p.m. until 6 p.m. Thursday, March 18, followed by an Opening Night Vernissage from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. Opening Night will benefit Phoenix Art Museum after drawing some 7,500 guests last year.
The fair continues from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Friday, March 19, and Saturday, March 20, before closing out its Third Edition from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Sunday, March 21.
Early Bird ticket pricing is available for a limited time, with Single-Day General Admission passes priced at $40, Student Admission at $20, Multi-Day Passes at $80, First Look tickets at $100 and Opening Night Vernissage tickets at $150.
Standard ticket prices range from $25 Student Admission and $50 Single-Day General Admission passes to a $100 Multi-Day Pass covering all three public days. First Look tickets are $125 and include early access to the fair, while Opening Night Vernissage tickets are $200. Scottsdale Art Week is free to attend for children 12 and under, and all tickets are available at ScottsdaleArtWeek.com.
For more about Scottsdale Art Week, visit ScottsdaleArtWeek.com or stay connected via Facebook, Instagram and X.
.
Bortolameolli, who was announced as the Symphony’s new Virginia G. Piper Music Director Designate in March 2026, brings an international perspective and dynamic artistic vision to the orchestra as it begins this new era.
The 2026/27 Season offers more than 35 performances spanning beloved classical masterworks, acclaimed guest artists, Phoenix Pops® favorites, blockbuster films with live orchestra, holiday traditions, chamber music, family programming and special experiences throughout the Valley.
“This season represents an extraordinary moment for The Phoenix Symphony as we begin a new chapter with Music Director Designate Paolo Bortolameolli,” said Peter Kjome, President and CEO of The Phoenix Symphony. “This season offers something for everyone, from the great composers and masterworks that define the symphonic tradition to the films, artists and contemporary experiences that bring new audiences to the orchestra. We invite our community to experience this season with us.”
A New Chapter Begins
The 2026/27 Season opens with newly appointed Virginia G. Piper Music Director Designate Paolo Bortolameolli, who leads The Phoenix Symphony in Paolo Conducts Rachmaninoff & Prokofiev, October 9–11 at Symphony Hall. The program features Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 3 performed by celebrated pianist Olga Kern, a Gold Medalist of the Van Cliburn International Piano Competition, and Prokofiev’s powerful Symphony No. 5. The program opens with Glinka’s dazzling Overture to Russlan and Ludmilla.
Among the season’s other Classics highlights are Beethoven’s 7th Symphony and Chopin’s 2nd Piano Concerto; Schumann and Barber; Bruch and Mendelssohn with concertmaster Rolf Haas; a celebration of John Williams’ 95th birthday; Bortolameolli leading The Rite of Spring; Prokofiev’s Piano Concerto No. 3 with pianist Joyce Yang; and Mahler’s 5th Symphony.
Guest conductors and artists throughout the season bring additional perspectives and extraordinary talent to the Symphony stage, including Joyce Yang, Michelle Cann and Bella Hristova.
Phoenix Pops®
The 2026/27 Phoenix Pops season welcomes Stuart Chafetz as the Symphony’s new Principal Pops Conductor, making official a relationship with Phoenix audiences that has become a favorite over the years.
The Pops lineup offers an eclectic mix of legendary music, contemporary favorites and spectacular live experiences, beginning with Music of the Knights: Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber, Sir Elton John & Sir Paul McCartney.
Additional highlights include the Holiday Pops Spectacular, The Music of Paul Simon, Cirque Adventure with Troupe Vertigo, The Taylor Swift Symphonic Experience, Mandy Gonzalez Sings Lin-Manuel Miranda, and Symphonic Genesis & Phil Collins.

Photo by Jaron Quach for Tavit’s Photography
Films, Special Performances and New Experiences
The Symphony’s popular film concerts return with some of cinema’s most memorable scores performed live by The Phoenix Symphony.
The season includes Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl™ in Concert, Elf™ in Concert, E.T.™ in Concert, Top Gun: Maverick™ in Concert, and Raiders of the Lost Ark™ in Concert.
The season also features special performances including Final Symphony: Music from Final Fantasy, bringing the music of the iconic video game series to Symphony Hall; Fleetwood Mac: A Symphonic Tribute, celebrating the legendary band’s timeless music; and SYMPHONYFUSE: MAHLER X NOTORIOUS B.I.G X 2PAC, continuing the Symphony’s exploration of innovative musical fusions.

This landmark law firm combination will provide clients across Arizona and New Mexico access to a broader bench of lawyers and legal services, including Fennemore’s proprietary technology and innovation platforms through Project BlueWave AI.
Together, and operating under the Fennemore name, these two firms will unite their deep roots in Phoenix and long-standing relationships with the businesses, industries, and communities that have helped shape Arizona. G&K adds established relationships and significant experience in natural resources, environmental, water, business law, and litigation, as well as an
established New Mexico presence through its Santa Fe office. The combined firm will include more than 300 lawyers and legal professionals in Phoenix and more than 800 across its broader platform.
“Both Fennemore and Gallagher & Kennedy have played an important role in the growth of Phoenix and Arizona for generations,” said James Goodnow, CEO of Fennemore. “It is rare to have the opportunity to bring together two firms with this much history, this caliber of talent, and such strong client relationships. We know each other, we respect what each firm has built, and we believe we will be even better together.”
“Uniting is a significant opportunity for our clients and our people,” said Kevin O’Malley, managing partner and shareholder of Gallagher & Kennedy. “Gallagher & Kennedy has built its reputation on strong relationships, practical counsel and a deep understanding of our clients and the communities we serve. Joining Fennemore will give our clients access to additional resources and capabilities, while giving two groups of people who know and respect one another the opportunity to work as one team.”

Electronic Music Duo Joins Alaskan Franks and Walter Productions for a Full Day of Music, Polo and Entertainment Nov. 7 at WestWorld

The 15th annual Bentley Scottsdale Polo Championships has found the soundtrack for a milestone anniversary, with electronic music duo Phantoms set to bring its mix of house and indie-dance to WestWorld of Scottsdale this November.
Phantoms, featuring Kyle Kaplan and Vinnie Pergola, will headline the DJ lineup at the nation’s most-attended polo event Saturday, Nov. 7, 2026, at 16601 N. Pima Road, Scottsdale, bringing even more energy to a day already packed with international polo, fashion, luxury cars, live entertainment and over-the-top experiences. Local duo Alaskan Franks, which includes Ladell Ransom and Frank Terry, will join Phantoms on the DJ lineup, giving Arizona talent time in the spotlight alongside the nationally touring headliner.
The music continues after the last polo match when Walter Productions rolls out Kalliope, its massive mobile sound stage, for the Sunset After-Party. Known for creating immersive experiences on a grand scale, Walter Productions has established a strong presence in Arizona’s entertainment scene with its music venues, production and fabrication work, and unmistakable fleet of oversized art cars. Since 2009, the Walter Productions team has taken its larger-than-life creations beyond the Valley to festivals and events across the country. The full entertainment lineup gives Scottsdale Polo Party guests plenty to listen to between matches —
and another reason to stick around until, and after, dark.
“Walter Productions is proud to be part of the 15th annual Polo Championships,” said Walter Productions’ Kirk Strawn. “As always, the event brings some of the most eclectic and innovative cultural contributions to our Valley.”
Kaplan and Pergola launched Phantoms in 2016 and have spent the decade since building a sound that combines house, indie-dance and alternative electronica.
“Just a Feeling” featuring Vérité, from Phantoms’ self-titled debut album, spent four consecutive weeks at No. 1 on U.S. Dance Radio and set a record on SiriusXM BPM’s Top 20 countdown. Phantoms followed its successful debut with the 2019 Disconnect EP featuring dance-chart hit “Say It,” and earned support from some of electronic music’s biggest names, including Pete Tong, Diplo, Duke Dumont, Martin Garrix and Jai Wolf.
This year’s event will pit England’s Select against Dark Horse Dallas in a first-ever Scottsdale matchup. The championships will also feature The Arizona Polo Club and New Orleans Polo Club squaring off in the opening match, along with Army vs. Navy in the Semper Fi Heating and Cooling Military Matchup just days before Veterans Day.
Past attendees will also find plenty of new elements at this year’s festivities, including Best of the West: The Inaugural Arizona State Acoustic Guitar Championships, and the event’s first-ever rugby match between the nationally ranked Scottsdale Blues Rugby Team and San Diego Old Aztecs.
Guests can also check out an Arizona wine tasting experience, a new on-site sports bar and cigar lounge with Million Dollar Mingle and the Scottsdale Polo Party’s first Western Pleasure Competition with the Scottsdale Arabian Horse Show.
Fashion will also again hit the field with Phoenix Fashion Week’s “The World’s Longest Catwalk,” Lugari Pet Salon’s Canine Couture dog fashion show and a new Cowgirl Couture show from Franklin, Tennessee-based Moo Country. Million Dollar Mingle will return as its own “event within the event,” while Riot House DayClub
and the Barrett-Jackson Champagne & Jazz Lounge will give guests even more places to kick back and take in all the action.
Then, as the sun sets over WestWorld, the Sunset After-Party gets underway.
“The music has become a huge part of the Scottsdale Polo Party,” said Bentley Scottsdale Polo Championships General Manager Mary Turner. “Phantoms bring exactly the kind of energy we want for our 15th anniversary, and pairing them with Alaskan Franks and Walter Productions gives people yet another reason to come out for polo and stay all day.”
Festivities will begin Thursday and Friday, Nov. 5 and 6, with welcome parties and VIP receptions for sponsors, players and ticketholders taking place before the main event hits WestWorld Saturday.
Tickets start at $45 and are on sale now at ThePoloParty.com, along with additional information about tables and sponsorship opportunities. Premium experiences include Prime, a Luxury Tent Experience by Bentley Scottsdale, Neiman Marcus, Barrett-Jackson and Maple & Ash; The Scottsdale Maserati Drivers & Players VIP Lounge; the Barrett-Jackson Champagne & Jazz Lounge; All Access passes; and Sideline Parking packages.

“Taryl brings the leadership, vision, and operational experience—both within and outside the Arabian horse industry—required to guide AHA through its next chapter,” said Lisa Blackstone, President of the AHA Board of Directors. “During our search process, we sought a leader capable of balancing our vision for the future with the change management required to make that vision a reality. Taryl’s passion for and experience with the Arabian horse, combined with her deep executive management background, make her uniquely suited for this role.”
“I am honored and thrilled to join AHA at such an important moment,” said O’Shea. “The mandate coming out of the Convention last year was clear—we need to unite our breed and execute a growth plan. This organization has such an important mission to fulfill. I look forward to working with the Board and our dedicated staff to position AHA for success in a 21st-century world. We must become relevant to a broader audience while ensuring the long-term financial sustainability of the association.”
O’Shea brings more than 25 years of experience in the Arabian horse industry. She previously served as Executive Director of the Arabian Horse Association of Arizona for more than two decades, where she successfully managed and led the internationally recognized Scottsdale Arabian Horse Show. She has also served as Director of the Global Champions Arabians Tour – Americas, in addition to holding leadership roles in the automotive industry. O’Shea has been a member of AHA for nearly three decades.
Her educational background includes a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a master’s degree in business marketing, and executive education programs from Yale University and the University of Pennsylvania.
As CEO, O’Shea will focus on several strategic priorities, including:
• Unite – Unifying the broad and diverse community of Arabian horse owners, breeders, and enthusiasts
• Revamp – Refreshing how the Arabian horse is perceived by highlighting its beauty, athleticism, emotional intelligence, and rich history
• Market – Providing industry leadership in the promotion and marketing of the Arabian horse
• Grow – Expanding participation and significantly growing the Arabian horse community
• Innovate – Transforming Arabian horse shows into dynamic experiences that are fun, rewarding, entertaining, educational, and competitive for exhibitors and spectators alike
The Board also extends its appreciation to Stan Morey for his leadership and contributions to AHA during his tenure and for his commitment to ensuring a smooth leadership transition.
Featured Editorials

Scottsdale has long punched above its weight in health care, and the newest U.S. News Best Hospitals rankings confirm it again. HonorHealth Scottsdale Shea Medical Center once more lands among Arizona’s top-recognized hospitals, a distinction it has now earned across multiple ranking cycles. That consistency matters more than any single year’s placement.

A Track Record That Keeps Building
Shea has previously been rated high performing across nine separate adult procedures and conditions, a breadth of strength that few hospitals in the state can match. This year’s recognition builds on that foundation rather than standing alone. Meanwhile, Mayo Clinic Arizona’s continued Honor Roll status reinforces something Scottsdale residents already sense: greater Phoenix, and this corner of it especially, has become a genuine destination for advanced care. Furthermore, national specialty rankings in areas like cardiology, orthopedics, and gastroenterology show the depth runs well beyond a single flagship institution.
Why This Recognition Matters Locally
These rankings are not just bragging rights for a hospital press release. They translate into real outcomes for the families who rely on this infrastructure every day, from emergency care to complex surgical procedures. HonorHealth’s showing also reflects years of investment in specialized units and physician recruitment, choices that take a long time to pay off. In fact, the broader Arizona health care landscape includes several strong systems across the Valley, and Scottsdale’s presence near the top says something specific about this community’s priorities. Consequently, residents get a rare advantage: nationally competitive care without leaving town.

A Point of Civic Pride Worth Repeating
Scottsdale rarely misses a chance to celebrate its restaurants, resorts, and retail openings, and it should extend that same pride to institutions like Shea Medical Center. Health care rankings do not move quickly or reward hype, so a hospital that keeps showing up near the top is doing something durable and real. That is worth applauding every time the rankings come back around.
“I am deeply saddened by the passing of former U.S. Senator Jon Kyl, not only for the loss of this great man, but for what his passing represents to all Arizonans.
Senator Kyl was a statesman in every sense of the word. He was staunch in his beliefs, yet always sought compromise. Senator Kyl was quick to teach and eager to learn. He was also adamant that each of us play a vital role in the health of our Constitutional Republic.
I find it fitting, and nearly poetic, that his death was announced on Constitution Day. Senator Kyl built his legislative career around the U.S. Constitution and his reverence for it. He was a constructionist through and through, whose conservative lens made him a strong advocate for the separation of powers. I share this passion and am grateful for leaders like Senator Kyl, whose lives have honored the tenants of timeless conservativism.
Senator Kyl’s passing represents the end of a bygone era of politics in which disagreements didn’t mean the end of a discussion, but the beginning. A time when we reached for understanding rather than blame. He was a great man whose decades-long career serves as a reminder that decency, kindness, intelligence, and foresight will always triumph.
My family and I continue to pray for Senator Kyl, his loving family, and all those who cared for him. May his memory and legacy continue to inspire civility and humility in all of us.”

By Councilwoman Solange Whitehead

Should Scottsdale Residents Pay Double for Water?
The current Council majority has gone to great lengths—and at ratepayers’ expense—to work around Scottsdale’s Water Strategic Plan, an adopted plan designed to keep our water flowing, safe, and affordable.
The latest proposal would further delay Scottsdale’s Advanced Water Purification facility—the most cost-effective and secure source of new water—and could potentially double the cost of treating water.
The “big” idea? Discharge Scottsdale’s highly treated wastewater into the Central Arizona Project (CAP) system in exchange for raw CAP water. That CAP water includes treated wastewater from Nevada.
Here are a few questions and concerns:
- Should ratepayers pay twice to treat their drinking water? And not diversify?
Ratepayers will have to pay to treat water twice. First for the water discharged into the canal and again for the raw CAP water.
Let’s remember, our overdependence on Colorado River water is the problem. This proposal doubles down on the problem we must solve.
- How does this strengthen the regional water supply?
The City Manager says the proposal will “strengthen the regional supply.”
How? If Scottsdale puts a cup of water into the canal and takes a cup out, I don’t see how the regional supply has changed.
With our drinking-water shortage, it makes no sense to send treated water downstream.
- The real hurdle: How long will it take—and what will it cost.
This exchange isn’t allowed under current CAP rules. Changing it could take years, requiring approval from numerous CAP customers, including Native American tribes. Scottsdale’s water crisis can’t wait for that process—so why pursue it?
Can we just stick to the adopted Water Strategic Plan?
We have lost two years by delaying the final treatment work at Scottsdale’s Advanced Water Purification facility, which is already up and running. ADEQ rules are still evolving, but that shouldn’t prevent us from moving forward.
Meanwhile, Phoenix is building three advanced water purification facilities from the ground up under the same evolving regulatory framework.
Water is too important for politics. We need to follow the Plan, and focus on a secure water future—one that Scottsdale residents can trust and afford.

Scottsdale has never been shy about treating water like the scarce resource it is, and its latest pitch to offset Colorado River cuts proves it again. For decades the city has drawn roughly 70% of its supply from the Colorado River through the Central Arizona Project. However, federal shortage declarations and a shrinking Lake Mead have forced Scottsdale to get creative rather than simply cut back.

Lake Mead – Photo Credit: LATimes.com
A Two-Decade Head Start on Innovation
Scottsdale did not wake up to this crisis unprepared. The city has spent more than 20 years purifying recycled water and reinjecting it into the aquifer, a process that already supplies about 15% of daily demand. Now officials want to go further, piping that same ultra-purified water directly into the municipal drinking supply instead of routing it through groundwater storage first. That leap, called direct potable reuse, would make Scottsdale one of the few Arizona cities producing drinking water this way. Meanwhile, the city already holds Arizona’s first permit for direct use of recycled water, a distinction that speaks to genuine engineering ambition.
Weighing Cost Against Water Independence
The numbers have grown alongside the ambition. Early estimates pegged the advanced purification project at $15 million to $20 million, but current projections approach $100 million, pushing the timeline from 2027 out to 2030. Councilmember Solange Whitehead has argued the investment is worth it, framing the goal as greater water independence rather than dependence on a shrinking river. Not everyone agrees; Councilman Adam Kwasman has pushed back on the idea of reclaimed water reaching taps. Still, city staff under Water Resources leadership continue refining cost estimates and regulatory plans ahead of a spring presentation to council.
Innovation Beyond a Single Pipeline
The purification project is only one piece of a broader strategy. Scottsdale has also agreed to spend $8.25 million on 15,000 acre-feet of groundwater from the Harquahala Valley, and it continues studying a possible Bartlett Dam expansion alongside new demand management rules. Together, these moves show a city treating a genuine crisis as an engineering puzzle rather than a reason for panic.

Greg Caton. Photo Credit: City of Scottsdale
Extra credit is due to City Manager Greg Caton for his work. His work encapsulates the sort of innovation and leadership on a policy matter that sits second to few, including in the public safety space. That is the kind of forward-thinking planning other Arizona cities facing the same
By Lisa Haskell
Mom taught me to never follow the crowd because a crowd can become an unruly mob. I have always been more independent so when it came time for me to vote for the first time, I took the obligation seriously. I didn’t rely on others to do my research for me. I didn’t take anyone’s recommendation without doing my own ” homework” kind of like grade school. Don’t cheat. And, whatever you do, don’t write the multiplication tables ( the nines) on the palm of your hand in red marker before reciting them to the class. Your hands sweat and the red ink runs guaranteeing you will never know what 9×9 equals and your face will be as red as the ink running down your arm. So I was told..
In today’s world being the poster child for bad behavior is considered a badge of honor. I admit there is a time and place for that but you must decide if bad behavior should be rewarded with an elected office. Sadly, civility seems to have gone out of style. It’s a slander your opponent ( and their supporters ) , sweep your own misdeeds under the nearest rug, manipulate facts, outcomes and anything or anyone who gets in your way kind of world. Partisanship above all else. I honestly believe if Satan ran for public office he could win if he identified with the “right” party. Would he be a MAGA member or a DSA member? Hmmm…
Locally, we seem to be having a turf dispute as in no common ground. Disclaimer : I am not being rewarded monetarily by Axon or any other “dark money” group for my opinions. Friends and neighbors ask me who to vote for and my standard response is this. Do your own homework. Don’t copy off the kid who ate…paste in school. First, make a list of issues that are important to you . See where the candidates stand on those issues recognizing that you will never agree with someone 100% of the time. Start watching council meetings…painful though it might be. You can assess temperament and suitability to serve on council. Do they play well with others, compromise, work towards solutions ? Are they receptive to other points of view or is “Residents First” just a campaign slogan? Finally, look for evidence of involvement in the community other than rabid devotion to a political party. You can watch city council meetings live by going to the City of Scottsdale website. Viewing the meeting from the comfort of your home allows you to hurl expletives and other objects at the screen while sipping your favorite adult beverage. It’s a win, win.
I still care about the same issues I always have but I am ready to try something new. I am weary of bad behavior and refuse to reward it with my vote. Personal attacks, smear campaigns, manipulation of election results….I want to see if anyone can find common ground or has that gone the way of unobstructed views?
Lisa Haskell
Scottsdale

A Building That Didn’t Need to Grow Taller
George Oliver, a Scottsdale-based real estate firm, bought the office building at 7272 E. Indian School Road for $42.2 million. Paired with two earlier purchases on Scottsdale Road, the assemblage now totals 360,000 square feet. In total, it spans three buildings on six acres. Most Old Town projects chase value by going up. This one does not. George Oliver and its investment partner, Ascentris, are renovating the existing structures instead of demolishing them. Founder Curt Kremer called it an effort at “honoring the character of the site’s existing buildings.” The goal, he said, is “thoughtfully transforming them” rather than starting over. In other words, no new floors and no zoning fight over height. Just a smarter use of what was already standing.

The site in question. Photo Credit: AZ Big Media
Value Added From the Inside Out
The project, called Arbor Old Town, leans on design rather than density to justify the price tag. Architect Jay Sciarani described it as a chance to put “wellness, hospitality and placemaking at the core” of office space. The campus will include a central courtyard called The Garden, complete with fireplaces and hanging daybeds. In fact, a vintage Winnebago serves as a café. Beyond that, there is a wellness center with a cold plunge, a 160-person training room, and a golf simulator lounge. It sounds indulgent, and it is. However, none of it required tearing anything down. Tenants have already noticed. Symmetry Software, a Gusto subsidiary, is relocating its headquarters there from Northsight. Meanwhile, a fintech firm has leased another 15,000 square feet.

Photo Credit: AZ Big Media
What Old Town Should Learn From This
Gallery owner Bob Pejman put it simply. “This is an example of a very good project,” he said. It “repurposes and enhances an existing three story office building,” he added, “by adding desirable and high-end features.” He called it “a net positive for Old Town.”; a distinction that matters. So much of Old Town’s recent development has followed a knock-it-down, build-it-up playbook. It stacks height onto small parcels and asks neighbors to live with the consequences. Arbor Old Town proves that is not the only path to a return. Creative interior design and a genuine respect for existing architecture can do the same job. Notably, none of it changes the skyline. Completion is targeted for later this year. If the leasing momentum holds, Scottsdale should be paying close attention. This is what development done right actually looks like, and the city could use a lot more of it.
Campaigns have a way of reducing people to mailers, slogans and thirty-second advertisements. But the Raoul Zubia I know is much easier to describe: he is a good man who genuinely cares about Scottsdale.
Raoul was born and raised here. Scottsdale isn’t someplace he moved to and decided to get involved in; it is home. His memories are here. His friendships are here. His family is here. And his commitment to this community didn’t begin when he decided to run for City Council.
For years, Raoul has quietly done the work.
He has served Scottsdale through the Human Services Commission, the Protect and Preserve Scottsdale Task Force, Partners for Paiute, our schools, charitable organizations and community events. If there is work to be done, Raoul has never needed his name at the top of the program before agreeing to help.
That tells you something about a person.
I’ve also watched how Raoul treats people. He listens. He asks questions. He doesn’t assume the person across the table is an enemy simply because they disagree. In today’s politics, that quality is becoming far too rare.
Raoul isn’t interested in turning every disagreement into a fight. He wants to understand the problem, gather the facts and figure out what will actually work.
Scottsdale City Council could use more of that.
This election will feature plenty of arguments about policies and votes, as it should. But character matters too. Temperament matters. Judgment matters.
I’ve known Raoul outside the campaign spotlight. The person voters see today is the same person his friends have known for years: thoughtful, dependable, hardworking and deeply proud of this community.
That’s why I’m supporting my friend Raoul Zubia for Scottsdale City Council.
Doreen is a Community Philanthropist
By Bobby “Rob” Birmingham
Barry Graham and his minions have spent weeks repeatedly criticizing Raoul Zubia over support from the Realtor Association. Their social media trolls continue to spread lies and disinformation about Realtors.
Ironically, Graham’s own campaign finance reports show nearly $50,000 in contributions from people tied to real estate, development, property management, and related business interests.
Want the receipts? Names include John Graham of Sunbelt Holdings, Daniel Slack and Warren Baker of Baker Development, Jay Rollins of Canopy Real Estate, Howard Lein of Excalibur Realty, Gary Bohall of Scottsdale Land Co., Cynthia Simonson of Simonson Buildings, and Realtors including Lisa Lucky, David Boudreau, Kris Boudreau, and Valerie Teich.
The hypocrisy is astounding.
Graham has tried to frame himself as anti-development and make his opponent look like a development demon. The only person running in this race who has actually voted for more development is Barry Graham.
More receipts:
Cosanti Commons 196 apartments: On December 3, 2024, Graham voted to approve the rezoning for Cosanti Commons near Shea Boulevard and 70th Street. The project includes 196 apartments plus commercial space.
Legacy North 443 units: On January 18, 2024, Graham was among the Development Review Board members voting 6–1 to approve the design plans for Legacy North Apartments at Crossroads, a 443-unit multifamily development. This was a design-plan approval rather than the same type of rezoning vote as Cosanti Commons.
Maybe that’s why he takes so much of that industry’s money?
If Graham and his cohorts’ argument is that real estate-related money deserves scrutiny, Graham’s own donor list is part of that discussion too.
The same standard should be applied consistently to both campaigns.

464 Days and Counting
Corbin Burnes made his long-awaited 2026 debut on September 8. He threw three scoreless innings in an 11-inning win over the Royals. It capped a 464-day rehab that began with Tommy John surgery in June 2025. The road got even longer this June, when he strained his teres major during a bridge outing. Burnes signed a six-year, $210 million contract with Arizona in December 2024. He then made just 11 starts before his elbow gave out. He could have coasted through a lost season on that money. Instead, he logged a rehab start with Triple-A Reno. Beyond that, he threw a bridge camp game in Tempe, 53 pitches across three innings, just to prove he was ready. “Now we can stop talking about how long it has been,” Burnes said after the win. “Let’s just get back to playing baseball.”

Corbin Burnes. Photo Credit: Fox Sports
A Different Kind of Absence
Ketel Marte’s path back looked nothing like that. In August, Marte no-showed a game in Boston. For instance, manager Torey Lovullo said he “didn’t get much back from him” when he tried to reach out. The Diamondbacks placed Marte on the restricted list. Soon after, they moved him to the injured list for a sore left knee. Even so, fans booed him in his first at-bat when he returned. Marte offered a blunt explanation for the missed game. “It’s a moment of frustration,” he said, adding, “I failed him by not showing up.” Notably, this marked the fourth straight season Marte has missed a game without authorization. His numbers have slipped too. As a result, he is hitting .249 with 21 home runs, a steep drop from the near-MVP form that earned him back-to-back All-Star nods.

Ketel Marte. Photo Credit: Wikipedia
What Arizona Actually Needs
Major League Baseball doesn’t exist in a vacuum. The Diamondbacks are locked in a tight Wild Card race. Currently, they sit half a game ahead of San Diego heading into September. Three head-to-head games in late September could decide the final spot. Naturally, Lovullo called Burnes’ return “a manager’s dream.” Meanwhile, Marte remains in the lineup, and Arizona still needs his bat down the stretch. Still, the contrast between these two comebacks is hard to ignore. One player fought for fifteen months just to earn back his roster spot. The other, signed through 2031 on a $116.5 million extension, walked away from his team mid-race. Ultimately, he needed a knee MRI and an apology to make it right. In the end, Arizona fans noticed the difference. So did the standings.
By Allen Frank
While Mr. Nelson reviews campaign finance reports, he should look at Mr. Zubia’s.
Short-term rentals have plagued Scottsdale since the State stripped cities of zoning power. The Realtors of Arizona PAC — Zubia’s largest donor at $8,000 — has taken credit for stopping bills that would return local control. One legislator calls them the “biggest obstruction” to STR reforms. Why does the STR lobby prefer Zubia, and how would he vote on STRs?
The Bar District is the epicenter of Scottsdale’s crime. One of its dominant operators is on Zubia’s financials. Why does the Bar District seemingly prefer Zubia, and how would he vote on their applications?
Axon lobbied the Legislature to nullify Scottsdale’s referendum on its 2,000-apartment campus. Zubia accepted $5,000 from Axon’s president, and an Axon-linked PAC has spent over $250,000 to defeat Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita and elect Zubia. On 12News, Brahm Resnik asked why Axon supports him. Could Zubia ever tell Axon no?
Zubia also accepted $1,500 from partisan North Scottsdale Democrats, who spent another $1,100 attacking Graham. City government should be non-partisan — Why is a partisan group investing in Zubia, and how would he choose between party and Scottsdale?
Zubia was endorsed by the Democrat Socialists. They don’t endorse candidates unless they are of their ilk.
Let’s carefully review Zubia’s finances Mr Nelson.
Allen Frank

A Second Cancellation in as Many Weeks
Saguaro has called off its game against American Leadership Academy-Queen Creek, scheduled for September 11. The district cited a simple reason: there were “not enough healthy and available student-athletes to safely field a team.” This is the second straight week a Saguaro game has disappeared from the schedule. We covered the first cancellation against Chaparral, and warned then that it looked like more than a one-week problem. That warning held up faster than expected.
How a 14-Time Champion Got Here

During better days
The roster math explains the panic. Saguaro opened the season with a 62-0 loss to Desert Mountain. Injuries from that game left the varsity roster at just 25 players. Roughly 35 players have transferred out of the program over the past two seasons. The coaching carousel did not help. Darius Kelly was fired after going 4-16 across two years. His replacement, Jason Ronquillo, quit before coaching a single game. Butch Goncharoff won 11 state titles at a Washington high school before taking over in February. He inherited just 14 players. Since then, he has rebuilt the roster to roughly 35 by merging the freshman and JV teams into varsity. That is five head coaches since 2022, at a program that has won 14 Arizona state titles since 1995. Broader SUSD turmoil sits in the background too.
What This Might Mean for Saguaro’s Future
Goncharoff insists the season will continue. “We are not canceling the season,” he said, and Saguaro is still scheduled to host Mountain Ridge on September 18. However, two cancellations in two weeks suggest a program running on fumes rather than momentum. A roster this thin cannot absorb many more injuries before it simply cannot field a team at all. Even a strong coach with a championship résumé needs bodies to coach, and Saguaro does not have many to spare.

Photo Credit: On3
If the pattern continues, expect more late-week cancellations rather than blowout losses. The district appears committed to player safety over playing shorthanded. Longer term, this likely means a rebuilding window measured in years, not months. Talented players do not transfer back quickly once they leave. A shortened schedule this fall makes it harder to convince the next freshman class that Saguaro football is still worth their time. The dynasty is not dead. It is, for now at least, on life support.

On the morning of 9/11, I was in a skyscraper in Pittsburgh as the attacks unfolded. We knew another plane had been hijacked somewhere over Pennsylvania, but we did not know where it was or where it was headed. Then came the news from Shanksville — and, later, the story of what its passengers and crew had done.
Less than an hour after United Flight 93 left Newark, four al Qaeda terrorists seized the plane and forced the passengers and crew to the rear of the aircraft. “
Read the full piece here
In 2017 Scottsdale became a Golden Rule City: “Treat others as you would like to be treated.” The City Council’s Civil Dialogue principles ask us to patiently listen, speak respectfully, and own our words.
We expect leaders to live by that.
We have seen many Scottsdale elections, some more than others, in which candidates abide by that principle. Unfortunately, this election has been one of the most uncivil in recent memory. While most candidates have campaigned on the issues, the exception is Raoul Zubia, who has circulated doctored photos, called his opponents “cowards” and “whiners,” joked about candidates “crying,” and used smears on his street signs.

By John Nelson
Councilmember Barry Graham’s vote for the controversial Brown Avenue parking garage raises legitimate questions about the appearance of a conflict of interest.
In 2019, Legacy Gallery owner Jinger Richardson was specifically identified among gallery owners who had pushed City Hall to address downtown parking shortages.
Fast forward to April 14, 2026. Graham voted to approve a $3.8 million first-phase contract for the Brown Avenue garage, part of a project budgeted at roughly $18 million, despite substantial opposition from residents and Old Town businesses.
Then, on May 7, Richardson contributed $1,000 to Graham’s reelection campaign. Graham’s own campaign-finance filing identifies her as the owner of Legacy Gallery.
Residents deserve transparency. Did Richardson or other Graham donors advocating for additional Old Town parking communicate with him about this garage? Were meetings held before the vote? Did the Farmers Market come up?
If so, Graham should release those communications.
When elected officials approve multimillion-dollar projects benefiting priorities long advocated by political supporters without allowing there to be a study or clear justification, disclosure should not require a public-records request.
On this day, 25 years ago, nearly 3,000 Americans were tragically murdered in the most devastating terrorist attack in U.S. history.
In the quarter-century since September 11, 2001, we have bravely looked evil in the eye, called it by name, and condemned those responsible for the senseless violence. We have strived to show the world that we still fight for the same ideals and values that make America a beacon of freedom.
I encourage you to reflect on the strength and unity displayed across America following 9/11. I will never forget the sights of strangers embracing, first responders running into burning buildings, civilians carrying the injured, and neighbors who rallied for the grieving families. While it may feel as though those unifying moments have passed, I believe the greatest way to honor the lives lost is for a renewal of that communal spirit.
Today, I encourage you to act with kindness. Extend grace to a colleague having a hard time, hold the door for the person behind you, reach out to an elderly neighbor, or remind a child to thank a veteran for their military service. This day should serve as a reminder that our country’s darkest hours are always followed by inspirational examples of bravery, heroism, and sacrifice. Our inherent goodness always wins out.
As we remember the leaders, first responders, and everyday people who came together to help in the wake of 9/11, I want to extend my sincerest gratitude to those who protect us now. I’m grateful for our brave Emergency Management Team at Maricopa County, fearlessly led by Director Frank McWilliams, Assistant County Manager Blanca Caballero, and County Manager Jennifer Pokorski.Read More

In furtherance, the mayor is convening a summit of Entertainment District stakeholders and decisionmakers geared toward protecting public confidence in one of the country’s premier entertainment destinations.
Mayor Borowsky’s initiative follows unanimous City Council support for her recently agendized proposal to strengthen Scottsdale’s Public Safety Plan ordinance in entertainment-based establishments, including potential reforms and stronger security requirements for businesses covered under the ordinance.
“The recent violence in Old Town is unacceptable; I am confident the area’s stakeholders and business owners agree. Together, we will work to identify enhanced security measures that serve to reduce safety compromising incidents and create an overall better experience.” Mayor Borowsky said.
“Scottsdale is one of the safest cities in America, a longstanding reputation that the current City Council continues to prioritize and strengthen. We will not tolerate the actions of a handful of bad actors to threaten that reputation, endanger public safety or undermine the businesses that depend on a safe and welcoming environment.”
Among the issues under consideration are enhanced training standards and other measures aimed at preventing violence, deterring criminal activity and improving public safety in high-traffic entertainment venues.
“It is important that any security enhancements the city seeks to impose be crafted with the input and, ideally, with consensus, from the area’s stakeholders,” Mayor Borowsky points out.
Of Note: Updates and recommendations will be developed with the support of the City Council Community Safety Subcommittee.
Mayor Borowsky has called a Public Safety Summit for Friday, Sept. 11, bringing together operators from Scottsdale’s Entertainment District and city leadership to examine recent incidents and identify immediate and viable solutions.
The meeting will focus on security practices, coordination between businesses and law enforcement, crowd management, patron safety, operational standards and other measures designed to prevent violence and disorder before they occur.
“Public safety is not an afterthought,” Mayor Borowsky said.
“Every business in the Entertainment District benefits from Scottsdale’s safe and robust reputation, and every stakeholder is encouraged to be part of the solution. We are bringing the decision-makers to the table to discuss what is working, what is not and what additional steps should be implemented to better protect residents, visitors and employees.”
Mayor Borowsky contends the city is prepared to take a close look at whether existing public safety requirements are sufficient to meet today’s challenges.
“Nobody should come to Old Town wondering whether they will be safe,” Mayor Borowsky said. “Once improvements are identified which strengthen our Public Safety Plan ordinance, security training or enhance accountability, then those must be implemented.”
The summit comes as city officials work to balance Scottsdale’s vibrant nightlife economy with the need to maintain order, protect patrons and support responsible business operators who have invested heavily in the district’s success.
“Our objective is simple,” Mayor Borowsky said. “I fully support a thriving and successful Entertainment District, but that success is conditioned upon a foundation of safety.”
By Don Henninger
When Raoul Zubia talks about Scottsdale, you can tell right away that this isn’t just a city to him. It’s home.
Raoul was born and raised in Scottsdale, and he has seen it change and grow over the years. He knows what makes the city special because he has lived it. He knows the neighborhoods, the people, the traditions, and the institutions that make Scottsdale what it is.
That personal connection is a big part of why Raoul has given so much of his time to serving the city.
He’s always been interested in public service and the value of being involved. He has served on the Human Services Commission, the Protect and Preserve Scottsdale Task Force, Partners for Paiute, education organizations, and lots of other community efforts.
That says a lot about who Raoul is. He believes that being part of a community means showing up, getting involved and pitching in.
You can count on Raoul. If he says he’s going to do something, he follows through. He listens to people, even when the conversation is difficult, and he genuinely wants to understand different points of view.
Scottsdale has important decisions ahead. Growth, water, infrastructure, public safety and preserving the character of our neighborhoods are complicated issues. They aren’t going to be solved with political slogans or easy answers. They will be solved by leaders who have a track record of serving the city, willing to do the hard work to make good things happen.
That is Raoul. He is steady, hardworking, thoughtful, and genuinely committed to Scottsdale. Most importantly, he cares about this community because it has always been home.
And that’s why I trust him to help lead Scottsdale into the future.
Don Henninger of Scottsdale is co-director of the Arizona Democracy Resilience Network.
By Al Simms
There is something refreshingly old-fashioned about a candidate simply sitting down, taking questions and answering them.
That is what Raoul Zubia did on Sunday Square Off.
No hiding behind a press release. No anonymous blog post. No surrogate going to bat for him. Zubia sat across from Brahm Resnik and discussed the issues Scottsdale’s next City Council will actually confront.
Viewers got to hear his answers, assess his command of the issues, and decide for themselves whether they agreed.
That should not be remarkable. Unfortunately, it increasingly is.
Zubia is one of three candidates competing for two council seats, along with Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita. Scottsdale confirms all three will appear on the November ballot. Resnik said during the interview that Graham and Ugenti-Rita declined invitations to appear.
And yes, the conversation got wonky at times.
Good.
Water policy is complicated. Scottsdale has been recycling water for decades and currently recharges nearly two billion gallons of highly purified recycled water into the aquifer each year. Serious questions about that system deserve more than slogans.
The same is true of development, economic growth, and technologies such as Flock, which Scottsdale is currently reviewing amid broader privacy concerns.
Meanwhile, Scottsdale’s political bubble will obsess over endorsements, disclosed contributions, and personalities. Michelle Ugenti-Rita has, for example, publicly celebrated an endorsement from Turning Point Action. Those political relationships are fair subjects for scrutiny.
But they are not substitutes for candidates answering questions directly.
Scottsdale voters deserve substantive interviews with everyone asking to govern the city.
On Square Off, one candidate accepted that opportunity. Zubia showed up.

A Vote Rooted in Real Concerns
Roughly 250 doctors, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants at Arizona Banner Medical Group voted better than two-to-one to unionize with the Union of American Physicians and Dentists. The concerns behind that vote are specific and worth taking seriously on their own terms. Clinicians have described no cap on how many primary care patients they’re assigned, pushing wait times out three to four months. They’ve described administrative work that doesn’t fit into the hours allotted for it, done unpaid, after hours. One primary care physician put her weekly hours at around 60. A nurse practitioner said the workplace culture leaves people feeling like they’re walking on eggshells. These are the kinds of complaints that tend to reflect real strain, not just a difficult negotiating tactic.

Part of a Longer Conversation
This isn’t the first time this year we’ve looked closely at Banner Health. We covered the $31.5 million malpractice verdict in which the fetal heart monitoring records central to the case went missing. We covered a state land transaction that drew scrutiny over how it was priced relative to comparable purchases. And we noted, earlier this year, an MIT Sloan review of more than 150,000 hospital employee reviews that ranked Banner near the bottom nationally on nurse satisfaction, alongside a proposed Scottsdale hospital expansion that drew comparison to how Flagstaff voters responded to a similar proposal there.
A Pattern, Not a Verdict
Any one of these episodes could reasonably be treated as an isolated setback, and we’re not suggesting otherwise. But taken together, alongside a union vote driven by clinicians describing real strain, it’s fair to ask whether Banner has a communication and accountability gap worth addressing, separate from the merits of any single incident. That’s a question for the organization to answer, not one we’re answering for them.
What Happens Next
The vote still needs certification from the National Labor Relations Board, and contract negotiations typically take a year or two once that happens. Banner has said it will consider its next steps once certification is complete. Whatever the eventual contract looks like, this vote is one more data point for anyone trying to understand how Banner Health is navigating a stretch of scrutiny, and how it chooses to respond will say a lot about where things go from here.
2026 Scrum
Residents who support Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita — or the many who have doubts about Raoul Zubia — are focusing on the issues: the connection between high-density apartments and water security, short-term rentals, neighborhood safety, the Bar District, and civility, along with an out-of-state super PAC spending huge sums to tip the election.
Zubia’s supporters have taken different approaches, like using cruel labels, mean-spirited innuendo, and whataboutisms that never quite answer the question that was asked. Some are recounting that Mr. Zubia was born here, that he’s friendly, and that he cares.
If this election were only about candidates’ roots, it would be a toss-up. They all grew up here and graduated from local high schools: Graham from Chaparral, Ugenti-Rita from Desert Mountain, Zubia from Coronado.
If this election were only about character and temperament, Graham and Ugenti-Rita would be voters’ choices. Not only have their campaigns been more civil, but they’ve both been under relentless attacks from the same out-of-state special interests promoting Zubia.
However, since this election is about the issues, that’s what matters: who is writing the checks to campaigns, what gets built, who will secure our water, and who will protect our neighborhoods. Graham and Ugenti-Rita are the candidates whose supporters are willing to debate the issues. Zubia’s allies are not.
Voters should watch who’s discussing the issues — and who keeps changing the subject.
By John Ainley
January 6th insurrectionists, will be in Maricopa County later this
week.
This reminded me of Barry Graham’s endorsement of Alexander Kolodin
for Arizona Secretary of State.
Kolodin was directly involved in efforts challenging Arizona’s 2020
election results. He served as local counsel in Sidney Powell’s failed
“Kraken” lawsuit seeking to overturn the result, litigation that later
led to him being admonished by the State Bar of Arizona and placed on
probation. He represented Arizona Republican Party Chair Kelli Ward as
she fought a subpoena from the congressional committee investigating
January 6. Kolodin’s association through these bad actors with this
shameful episode in American history makes him complicit with
cop-beaters.
Now Kolodin is running to oversee Arizona’s elections and Barry Graham
is publicly backing him. The same Barry Graham who touts POSA support
and claims he’s just here to put residents first. But by endorsing
Kolodin, Barry is putting his weight behind a guy who doesn’t think
residents should get a say in how they vote.
This matters in Scottsdale, where roughly two-thirds of voters
historically cast ballots by mail. Kolodin has supported legislation
to shorten early voting, ban vote centers and require voters to
repeatedly verify their address to continue receiving an early ballot.
He also sponsored a 2026 ballot measure imposing new voter-ID
requirements that critics warn could make mail voting significantly
harder.
So where does Barry Graham stand?
Does he believe Joe Biden won Arizona in 2020? Does he condemn the
effort to overturn that result? What are his views of January 6? Does
he support Scottsdale residents’ continued ability to conveniently
vote by mail? Does he support Kolodin’s proposals to fundamentally
change Arizona’s early-voting system?
Graham made these questions relevant when he endorsed Kolodin for the
office that administers our elections.
If Barry supports Kolodin, he should answer these questions and
explain whether he also supports Kolodin’s record and election agenda.
John Ainlay
Scottsdale resident
By Jim Derouin
Jerome Garcia’s recent post makes several claims about Raoul Zubia that are preposterous and simply not true. Most glaring is the assertion that Raoul’s support comes “exclusively from Democrats and socialist factions.” That is pure poppy cock.
Raoul’s publicly listed endorsers include Deb Gullett, a former Republican state representative, and Wes Gullett, a longtime Republican operative who served as an adviser to Senator John McCain and chief of staff to Republican Gov. Fife Symington. Deb Gullett was a Republican legislator and longtime Republican activist, while Wes Gullett was a Republican presidential elector for John McCain in 2008 and ran for Mayor of Phoenix against Greg Stanton.
Further, Raoul’s endorsement list includes former council candidate and conservative Crystal Caroll, Coconino County Assessor and Republican Jack Lunsford, numerous current and former local elected officials, business and community leaders, the Arizona Fraternal Order of Police, Scottsdale firefighters and Scottsdale REALTORS®, former Mayor Sam Campana, and former federal prosecutor and Republican Patrick Cunningham.
Does that sound like a coalition of Democrats and socialists?
Zubia has publicly rejected DSA. His campaign does not list DSA among its endorsements. The continued attacks and statements suggesting DSA involvement is irresponsible.
The claim that Zubia offers no substantive policy positions is also outright wrong and disproven by his published platform. His campaign specifically calls for water recycling, stronger enforcement of short-term-rental ordinances, development standards addressing height and traffic and more. Ignoring these facts is untrue and outright false.
Scottsdale voters deserve arguments based on the candidates’ actual records and positions. Fictionalized stories aren’t needed.
Raoul’s opponents, however, have become well known for spreading disinformation about water recycling and fellow councilmembers through anonymous social media sources. I may sound old, but I would like to bring back the days of Herb Drinkwater when members of the City Council put Scottsdale first rather than their own careers.
Raoul Zubia was born and raised in Scottdale. This is “home.” This is where he spent his professional career. This is where he has volunteered for innumerable civic activities for decades. His integrity is unchallengeable. If voters want someone who will put “citizens first,” he is the person. All this gibberish about Raoul being radical is silly talk that only makes conservatives of conscience want to back him more in order to make the City Council civil again.
I am writing to express my deep concerns regarding Raoul Zubia’s candidacy for the Scottsdale City Council. While his campaign materials claim a desire to return to “commonsense” and restore civility, his actual conduct on the campaign trail reveals a glaring double standard that is anything but unifying.
Mr. Zubia claims he will restore decorum to the council, yet his own campaign relies on name-calling and division. He has actively used street signs to refer to incumbent members as “clowns” and publicly labeled his opponents “cowards” simply for missing a debate due to prior commitments. This duplicitous style of campaigning is deeply divisive and directly contradicts his self-proclaimed mission of bringing civility back to our city’s leadership.
Furthermore, Mr. Zubia’s platform lacks substantive policy positions. Beyond vague campaign talking points about protecting neighborhoods, his campaign fails to offer concrete, detailed plans on how he would actually govern or advocate for Scottsdale residents on the council.
Finally, we must look closely at his assertions that he will work across the aisle with everyone. Despite these claims, his candidacy lacks any demonstrated support from local Republicans; his endorsements and backing stem exclusively from Democrats and socialist factions. A candidate who cannot bridge partisan divides during a campaign cannot be expected to foster true unity once elected.
Scottsdale deserves leaders who offer substance, respect, and a genuine ability to collaborate with all members of the community. Raoul Zubia’s divisive approach and lack of clear policy show his candidacy is not in the best interest of Scottsdale
Sincerely,
Jerome J. Garcia





