Opinion Columns Accepted

Featured Editorials

Marketplace

Scrum

Conservative's Corner


PHOENIX – Attorney General Brnovich announced today that the Attorney General’s Office awarded nearly $400,000 in grants to community organizations that provide mental health treatment and services to first responders. The organizations will assist firefighters, emergency medical services, and law enforcement across the state.

Four different grants were awarded to organizations, including the United Phoenix Firefighters (two separate grants), EMPACT Suicide Prevention, and Marana Health Center. Over 2,000 first responders and first responder families are expected to be served statewide over the next year through direct treatment, mental health services, and training.Read More

PHOENIX — Governor Doug Ducey announced today $300,000 in funding from the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund has been allocated to organizations across the state that support senior citizens, the homebound and those who are medically fragile. The funding will support organizations that have provided much needed aid to vulnerable populations impacted by COVID-19, by assisting with grocery shopping, meal deliveries, transportation to medical appointments, emergency errands and social interaction during a time of physical distancing.

“Arizona continues to focus on protecting public health, especially for those most at-risk like seniors and those medically vulnerable,” said Governor Ducey. “Volunteer and community organizations across the state are working day and night to provide support for those in their care through additional food deliveries, transportation and other services — and we’re proud to support their efforts. Thank you to everyone who has donated to the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund so we can protect at-risk Arizonans, and to everyone who has stepped up to help others.”

Recipients of the funding include:

  • Foundation for Senior Living (statewide)

  • Benevilla

  • Aster Aging

“We are so appreciative of this generous donation,” said Tom Egan, President and CEO of Foundation for Senior Living. “Our team has been working diligently to shift many of our programs to meal and food bag deliveries to seniors and adults with chronic health issues or disabilities. So far, we have seen our expenses increase by 25 percent and we’re anticipating the community will continue to need help throughout the summer. This donation will help offset our expenses and allow us to serve those in need.  We are so grateful to Governor Ducey and the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund!”

“We believe we are strongest when we work together,” says Joanne Thomson, President and CEO of Benevilla. “The support from the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund Now will help provide much needed services to the most vulnerable population in our community. Working together we are able to help seniors with grocery shopping, emergency errands and more, we are able to provide support and friendship to caregivers who might feel overwhelmed and alone and continue to support families in our community during this time.”

“The support that Aster Aging has received from the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund is truly making the difference for vulnerable older adults in the East Valley,” said Deborah Schaus, CEO of Aster Aging. “Requests for Meals on Wheels and our other basic need services have continued to grow as we strive to keep seniors safe during the pandemic.”

The AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund was established by Governor Ducey as part of the Arizona Together Initiative to provide financial support to non-profit organizations serving Arizonans most in need statewide. The AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund has collected more than $8.2 million to date. Arizonans can visit ArizonaTogether.org to learn more, donate and find volunteer opportunities.

PHOENIX — Governor Doug Ducey has announced that following a national search, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) has selected Arizona for its new U.S. advanced semiconductor factory. The project will create over 1,600 new high-tech jobs and generate thousands of additional jobs in the state for suppliers and other companies within the semiconductor industry. TSMC’s total spending on this project, including capital expenditure, will be approximately $12 billion from 2021 to 2029.

“We’re incredibly proud that one of the world’s leading technology companies has chosen Arizona for this high-tech project, one with national and global significance,” said Governor Ducey. “TSMC could have picked any place in the world to build this advanced manufacturing factory. They chose Arizona for our unbeatable business climate, already thriving tech sector and ready access to an international supply chain. I’d like to thank TSMC Chairman Dr. Mark Liu for his commitment to Arizona. We are honored to be selected for this project and look forward to building a collaborative long-term relationship with TSMC. I’m very grateful to President Donald Trump for his leadership and tireless efforts to bring more manufacturing back to our shores. I’d also like to thank Secretary Ross, his team at the U.S. Department of Commerce including SelectUSA, and the Trump administration for their partnership.”

Arizona has long been a hub for the advanced manufacturing and semiconductor industries. The state’s skilled workforce, strong supply chain, strategic geographic location, commitment to pro-innovation policies and unmatched quality of life have continued to drive rapid industry growth and economic momentum. This new U.S. facility will enable TSMC to provide enhanced service to customers and partners and increase its ability to attract global talent.

The facility will utilize TSMC’s 5-nanometer technology for semiconductor wafer fabrication and have the capacity to produce 20,000 wafers per month. Construction is planned to begin in 2021 with production targeted to start in 2024. The Arizona facility will be the company’s second manufacturing operation in the United States.

Several sites in the City of Phoenix are still being evaluated for the location of the factory. The Arizona Commerce Authority will continue working with TSMC, the U.S. administration, the City of Phoenix and the Greater Phoenix Economic Council to finalize all aspects of the project.

PHOENIX — With Arizona food banks experiencing a spike in demand, Governor Doug Ducey today announced a $500,000 grant from the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund for Arizona food banks to help fight hunger. Member organizations that are part of the Association of Arizona Food Banks/Arizona Food Bank, which is receiving the grant, supply a network of nearly 1,000 food pantries and organizations in all 15 counties in Arizona, some of which have experienced a demand up to five times greater than usual due to COVID-19.

“We want to make sure nobody goes hungry as we respond to COVID-19 and get people back to work,” said Governor Ducey. “With these dollars, Arizona food pantries across the state will be able to make more food deliveries and help more families, while implementing new protocols that prioritize public health such as drive-thru pick-ups. This grant is made possible because of the generous donations to the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund, and my thanks goes out to everyone coming together and pitching in to help Arizonans in need.”

The Association of Arizona Food Banks/Arizona Food Bank Network is comprised of five regional food banks, including:

  • St. Mary’s Food Bank Alliance

  • Desert Mission Food Bank

  • United Food Bank

  • Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona

  • Yuma Community Food Bank

The food banks will use the funding to address the spike in demand, including: meeting the needs of individuals with disabilities; acquiring more packaging materials to deliver food; securing additional storage space; implementing further adaptations to promote physical distancing among clients; coordinating convenient drive-through food pick-ups; and more.

“These unprecedented circumstances have created an increased demand for our services to support Arizonans who are struggling to provide the most basic needs for their families,” said Angie Rodgers, President & CEO of the Arizona Food Bank Network. “This gift from the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund will help to ensure small pantries in local communities stay open and ready for families in need during this time. We’re grateful for the support which will make a difference in our capacity to serve across the state.”

“Our deepest thanks to Governor Ducey and everyone who donated or raised money for the Arizona Coronavirus Relief Fund, making this gift to AzFBN possible. These dollars will help small food pantries statewide as they work to help Arizonans struggling with hunger,” said Michael McDonald, Chair of the Board of Directors, Arizona Food Bank Network, and CEO, Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona. “These charities are doing all they can to meet the increasing need, and this financial help for them truly couldn’t have come at a better time.”

The AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund was established by Governor Ducey as part of the Arizona Together Initiative to provide financial support to nonprofit organizations serving Arizonans in need.

The AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund has collected more than $8.2 million to date. In April, the Ben and Catherine Ivy Foundation donated $5 million to support the purchase of PPE including 1.1 million N-95 masks. Additional grant announcements will be made as disbursements are finalized.

Individuals and organizations interested in supporting the AZ Coronavirus Relief Fund can learn more about how to contribute at ArizonaTogether.org.

PHOENIX — Governor Doug Ducey today announced that the Stay At Home order in Arizona will be ending on May 15 and replaced by new guidance for the next stage of economic recovery. The new guidance aligns with gating criteria issued by the White House and Centers For Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and aims to mitigate the risk of COVID-19 resurgence, protect vulnerable populations, and guide the reopening of businesses with enhanced physical distancing and safety measures in place.

Arizona’s new Executive Order, which takes effect on Saturday, May 16, builds on Arizona’s comprehensive efforts to slow the spread of COVID-19 and protect public health, including: ramping up testing availability and frequency; implementing tracking of key health metrics such as reported symptomatic cases and emergency room usage; standing up surge hospital capacity to be used as needed; expanding statewide contact tracing; bolstering supply chains for personal protective equipment for frontline medical workers and emergency responders; implementing enhanced safety protocols to protect those living and working in high-risk facilities such as nursing homes; and providing public health guidance for businesses and individuals to ensure continued physical distancing.

“Since the start of this pandemic, Arizona has taken a calm and steady approach to protecting health and slowing the spread of COVID-19,” said Governor Ducey. “Today, our hospitals have capacity to provide care to those who need it; our businesses are implementing and adapting to new physical distancing measures; and data shows Arizona is headed in the right direction. It is time to move forward with the next steps of Arizona’s economic recovery — while continuing to make health and safety our number one priority. I’m grateful to all Arizonans for their partnership and cooperation during these trying times. By continuing to follow the data and recommendations of public health officials, we can continue to move forward safely and responsibly together.”

Governor Ducey also announced today an accelerated plan to test all staff and residents of long-term care facilities as well as individuals within Arizona’s prisons. As part of this plan, the Arizona Department of Health Services will partner with private-sector labs to expand testing to 147 long-term care facilities and provide antibody tests for correctional officers. Additionally, major league sports can resume limited reopening, without fans, this Saturday, May 16.

The Arizona Department of Health Services also released additional guidance for businesses and customers as more industries resume partial operations. This guidance includes:

  • Pools, with physical distancing and enhanced sanitation – can reopen Wednesday, May 13 (GUIDANCE)

  • Gyms & Fitness Providers, with physical distancing and enhanced sanitation – can reopen Wednesday, May 13 (GUIDANCE)

  • Spas, with physical distancing and enhanced sanitation – can reopen Wednesday, May 13 (GUIDANCE)

While never formally closed, many places of worship opted to temporarily change or suspend services in order to follow physical distancing guidelines. As they resume operations, the Arizona Department of Health Services released GUIDANCE for enhanced physical distancing and safety precautions.

View today’s Executive Order HERE.

View daily Arizona updates HERE.

Featured Editorials


Photo Credit: AZ Central

While Scottsdale gets plenty of attention for its upscale dining scene and luxury shopping, something equally exciting is happening just down the road in Mesa…and it’s a reminder that the Valley’s most interesting growth often comes as a result of its own maturity and diversity.

Mesa’s Asian District recently completed a $10 million expansion of Mekong Plaza, adding twelve new businesses and 32,000 square feet of retail and dining space. The project brings approximately 200 new jobs to the area and features exciting additions like Haidilao Hot Pot and Udon Shin, alongside more than 100 specialty shops serving the region’s growing Asian American community.

What makes Mekong Plaza particularly significant is its accessibility and inclusiveness. The plaza is directly accessible via Valley Metro light rail and bus routes, making it a true regional destination rather than an exclusive enclave. You don’t need a luxury car to experience authentic Vietnamese pho, browse specialty Asian grocers, or enjoy legitimate hot pot; you just need curiosity and a transit pass.

For Scottsdale residents who sometimes wonder if the Valley offers enough cultural depth beyond resort spas and steakhouses, Mesa’s Asian District provides a compelling answer. It’s a 20-minute drive from Old Town Scottsdale, yet it offers experiences you simply can’t replicate at another upscale mall or lifestyle center.

The expansion also represents smart urban planning. Rather than generic big-box retail or yet another strip mall, Mesa invested in cultivating a genuine cultural destination that serves both the local Asian American community and draws visitors from across the Valley. Mayor Mark Freeman emphasized that these “strong community partnerships” make Mesa a great place to live, with Chinese and Japanese staples enhancing the city’s appeal.

This is the kind of development that benefits everyone. Small business owners get opportunities to grow, the local economy diversifies, residents gain access to authentic cuisine and specialty goods, and the broader community becomes more culturally connected.

Scottsdale has its strengths: world-class resorts, art galleries, and fine dining. But the Valley thrives when different cities contribute their unique character. Mesa’s investment in Mekong Plaza shows that the most exciting growth doesn’t always come from luxury developments. Sometimes it comes from celebrating the communities already here and giving them room to flourish.

Next time you’re planning dinner, skip the usual Scottsdale spots and head east; explore the fruits of our beautifully diverse metroplex. Your taste buds, as well as your understanding of what makes the Valley special, will thank you.

By Councilwoman Jan Dubauskas

Dear Friends,

In business and in our personal lives, we seek the best deal – the biggest bang for our bucks. And, we shake our heads at cushy government contracts.

This week, Scottsdale City Council faced that exact situation. We are working to revitalize our Old Town area. And one aspect of it is a $1.3M advertising budget that will bring locals to dine, shop, and play in Old Town.

We were very excited for the opportunity to have a tremendous impact on Old Town… until we saw the contract. Of the $1.3M – after expenses, overhead, commissions – it was expected only 1/3rd of our dollars would actually go toward advertising.

Scottsdale deserves better than that! In the meeting, I highlighted these expense issues and urged my colleagues to reject the contract so that we can get a better deal for Scottsdale. I made the motion to deny the contract and although some wished to proceed, practical business-sense won the day.

My thanks to Councilwoman Littlefield, Councilman Graham and Vice Mayor Kwasman for standing strong throughout the session on this issue. We asked the city to do better and get more for your dollars.

And guess what?! The very next morning, the vendor reached out to us, offering to sharpen the pencil and deliver measurable results for Scottsdale.

Treating your dollars like we would treat our own – and being willing to say NO works. We are delivering results for you. 

Christmas At The Quarter

The more than 100 retail, dining, and entertainment businesses located in the Scottsdale Quarter welcomed the Christmas season by hosting the Santa Social. The event included photo opportunities with Santa, children’s entertainment, face painting and a variety of holiday crafts, games and music. Visits and photos with Santa will continue through Wednesday, December 24 with weekend entertainment, including live music, carolers and other seasonal family activities through Saturday, December 20th. For more click here.

We are working every day to serve you. If you have an issue or concern, please feel free to each out to our Constituent Services team:

1) 24/7 digital service request platform ScottsdaleEZ
2) Dedicated call center 480-312-3111 Monday-Friday 8am-5pm
3) Email constituentservices@scottsdaleaz.gov.

Upcoming Council meetings:

Next meeting: January 13, 2026.

Thank you for the opportunity to serve you. Scottsdale is a wonderful place to live. Our best days are ahead of us!

For Scottsdale!

Jan Dubauskas
Scottsdale City Councilwoman

Photo Credit: azcentral.com

Ah, Blackout Wednesday…or as the more refined among us prefer, “Drinksgiving.” The unofficial drinking holiday drew massive crowds to Scottsdale and Phoenix bars on Thanksgiving Eve, with venues like Coach House reporting their busiest night of the year.

If you ventured anywhere near Old Town Scottsdale last Wednesday evening, you witnessed a heartwarming American tradition: college students reuniting with high school friends, young professionals catching up over craft cocktails, and the entire Valley collectively deciding that nobody should cook the night before they have to cook all day Thursday.

One reveler summed up the evening’s ambitions perfectly: “I’m gonna get really drunk.” Truly, the poet laureate of our generation.

Old Town Scottsdale was absolutely buzzing with the kind of energy that makes this city special. The Pemberton hosted a full-on Friendsgiving party, while Coach House faced lines that staff described as “expected” for the busiest night of the year. Translation: if you showed up without a reservation, you’d better have been prepared to network your way in or stake out a corner of sidewalk real estate.

What makes Blackout Wednesday such a quintessentially Scottsdale event is how it perfectly captures the city’s ethos: work hard, play harder, and always look good doing it. Sure, other cities celebrate this pre-Thanksgiving tradition, but do they do it with our combination of patio weather, designer outfits, and an Old Town strip that offers more bars per square foot than almost anywhere else in the Valley?

The best part? Scottsdale actually handled it responsibly. Staff actively encouraged patrons to call ride-share services to get home safely, and judging by the surge pricing complaints flooding social media, plenty of people took that advice.

Yes, Blackout Wednesday has gained a somewhat notorious reputation nationally as one of the heaviest drinking nights of the year. But in Scottsdale, we prefer to think of it as “enthusiastic networking with enhanced social lubrication.” The long line at Coach House? That’s just eager residents supporting local business. The packed patios? Community building. But if we’re being completely honest, a city that can handle massive Barrett-Jackson crowds, endless bachelor parties, and spring training season can certainly manage one night of nostalgic college reunions and premature holiday cheer.

So here’s to Scottsdale’s Blackout Wednesday: where the drinks flow, the Ubers are plentiful, and our city’s hospitality industry proves once again why Old Town remains one of Arizona’s premier destinations for responsible(ish) revelry. Same time next year?

Photo Credit: AZ Central

Phoenix recently approved a controversial “middle housing” ordinance that will reshape how its historic neighborhoods develop. The decision, made under pressure from state law, allows duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes in areas previously zoned exclusively for single-family homes, including beloved historic districts like Willo, Encanto-Palmcroft, and Los Olivos.

The resistance was fierce. Neighborhood advocates warned of bulldozed century-old homes, decimated historic character, and communities fundamentally transformed beyond recognition. One resident predicted flatly that within a year, the landscape would be completely different and historic districts would be decimated.

But here’s the uncomfortable reality those concerns overlook: Arizona faces a severe housing affordability crisis, and Phoenix sits at its epicenter.

According to recent data, the typical home price in Arizona reached over $427,000 by March 2024, with median rent at $1,600. For minimum-wage workers, affordable rent would be $745 per month, just over half the cost of a one-bedroom apartment in Arizona’s current rental market. That means people with low incomes would need to work 76 hours a week to afford a one-bedroom apartment.

The choice Phoenix faced was stark: craft local rules to manage middle housing development, or let state law take effect automatically on January 1, potentially losing all local control over where and how multi-family structures are built. City officials chose pragmatism.

The fundamental question isn’t whether we value historic neighborhoods; it’s whether we value them more than we value housing accessibility for the next generation. When century-old homes become exclusive luxuries affordable only to the wealthy, have we truly preserved the community fabric, or just created attractive museums for the privileged?

Government’s role isn’t to lock neighborhoods in amber while housing costs spiral beyond reach. It’s to balance competing values with pragmatism; preserving what we can while ensuring communities remain accessible and economically diverse.

Phoenix made the practical choice: managing middle housing development locally rather than ceding control entirely. In a housing market where only 39% of Arizona employees at median wages can afford a one-bedroom apartment, that pragmatism isn’t just prudent policy…it’s a moral imperative.

Historic preservation matters. Housing affordability matters more. Finding solutions that address both, even imperfectly, is what responsible governance looks like.

By Bob Littlefield
Former Scottsdale City Councilman and Chairman of Taxpayers Against Awful Apartment Zoning Exemptions (TAAAZE)

The fight against Axon’s assault on democracy and profoundly frustrated Scottsdale residents isn’t going away despite a recent 4 to 3 Scottsdale City Council approval of the second largest multifamily housing project (1,200 units) in state history as well as undermining efforts to challenge the controversial rezoning in court and with the scheduled city-wide vote in November 2026.

I’m Chairman of TAAAZE (Taxpayers Against Awful Apartment Zoning Exemptions) which collected nearly 30 thousand signatures last fall to challenge Axon’s apartments.

We are still pursuing a lawsuit against Senate Bill 1543, the “Axon Bill,” which put certain rezoning decisions beyond the reach of voter challenges, including last year’s lame duck Scottsdale City Council approval of 1,900 units near Hayden and the 101. The first hearing on the state law is set for late January. Scottsdale’s approval is based on the state law. If found unconstitutional, Scottsdale’s Axon approval is meaningless and there will be no apartments to subsidize their controversial development plans.

Scottsdale City Council Members Adam Kwasman, Mary Ann McAllen, Solange Whitehead, and Mayor Lisa Borowsky voted yes on a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Axon that approved the unnecessary and unneeded 1,200 multifamily units. The city also agreed to abandon litigation against SB1543 and rescinded the previous zoning decision on Axon. The capitulation to Axon is shocking.

Additionally, at a time of drought the council majority released Axon of its obligation to provide water for its project. Who thinks this is a good idea?! And for the first time in Scottsdale history, the developer will govern itself when it comes to construction, rather than answer to City inspectors.

The council majority claims Axon will build 600 apartments and 600 condominiums yet included no language in the MOU or secured Axon agreement otherwise, meaning without such language and agreement, the mega Borowsky led approval is for 1,200 apartments.

Council Members Barry Graham, Jan Dubauskas, and Kathy Littlefield voted against the Axon apartment scheme.  We thank them.

TAAAZE is committed to the lawsuit against SB 1543 and is exploring additional lawsuits to prevent Axon from building 1,200 multifamily units in an area already dealing with massive traffic problems.  About 10,000 apartments are under construction or approved within five miles of this site.Read More

By Alexander Lomax

Former Scottsdale City Councilmember Tammy Caputi recently raised concerns about proposed changes to the city’s Rules of Council Procedure, scheduled for consideration on December 2. Her message has sparked an important conversation about what it means to truly engage with residents, even when that engagement is messy, time-consuming, or uncomfortable.

The proposed amendments would restructure public participation at council meetings, including consolidating two public comment periods into one, moving comments to the end of meetings, reducing speaking time from three to two minutes, restricting audiovisual equipment use, and requiring two weeks’ advance notice for citizen petitions. City staff has framed these changes as improvements to transparency and efficiency.

But here’s the thing about democracy: it’s supposed to be a little inefficient. It’s supposed to take time. It’s supposed to accommodate the unpredictable rhythms of civic life, not just the orderly progression of agenda items.

The real measure of “resident-friendly” government isn’t how smoothly meetings run or how quickly agendas move. It’s whether ordinary people with jobs, families, and limited time can still make their voices heard on issues that matter to them. It’s whether the process bends toward inclusion or convenience.

Transparency and public participation are most meaningful when they’re most accessible. That means accommodating the unpredictable, the unpolished, and the urgent. It means recognizing that sometimes the most important feedback comes without two weeks’ notice, and that visual presentations can communicate what words alone cannot.

Former Councilmember Caputi’s message serves as an important reminder: the goal should always be more engagement, not less. Better engagement, certainly, but never at the cost of accessible engagement. Local government works best when it actively invites participation, even when that participation is imperfect, inconvenient, or critical of the council itself.

The strength of Scottsdale’s civic culture will be measured not by how efficiently it can move through agendas, but by how authentically it can engage with the full spectrum of community voices—especially those that challenge, question, or simply show up unprepared but passionate about their city.

That’s democracy in action, and it’s worth protecting, even when it’s imperfect.

By Ronald Sampson

Photo Credit: Arizona PBS

Scottsdale Mayor Lisa Borowsky is facing a sudden and unusually sharp backlash after sources say she was booed at a meeting of the Palo Verde Republican Women; a group that once represented a reliable pocket of support. The reaction followed her vote in favor of a “compromise” agreement with Axon, clearing the way for a sprawling apartment development. For a mayor who campaigned on balanced growth and defending Scottsdale’s unique character, the blowback is more than just symbolic; it’s a warning shot.

And unlike some might hope, Scottsdale’s history suggests these early warning shots often echo for a long time.

When former Mayor David Ortega stumbled early in his term, particularly over development decisions that alienated activists and Republican clubs, the damage lingered. His relationship with grassroots organizations never fully recovered. Mary Manross, despite her professionalism and moderate tone, struggled for years to rebuild support after a general sense of waywardness; those struggles contributed to her eventual defeat. Even Sam Campana faced persistent criticism over development-related controversies that dogged her throughout her tenure and weakened her politically.

In Scottsdale, early missteps don’t always fade. They often define.

Borowsky now risks entering that same pattern. The Axon vote wasn’t just another zoning item; to many residents, it symbolized the broader, long-standing tension between preserving Scottsdale’s suburban identity and accommodating big corporate actors. And for some on the right, any suggestion of compromise, particularly with a powerful company, feels like capitulation rather than leadership.

The reaction from the Palo Verde Republican Women matters precisely because it comes from inside her own coalition. Moments like these can calcify quickly, especially if they feed into preexisting suspicions about a leader’s priorities.

To recover, Borowsky would need more than a few clarifications or town halls. She would need to demonstrate, consistently and strategically, that she is still aligned with the voters who put her into office. And even then, as Scottsdale’s recent mayoral history makes clear, rebuilding trust once lost is far from guaranteed.

The boos may have lasted only a moment. But the political consequences could linger much longer.

By ScottsdaleVoter

Photo Credit: Arizona PBS

For months Mayor Lisa Borowsky has flooded our mailboxes and social media with the same sermon: “I listen to residents,” “I’m protecting our water and our neighborhoods,” “your voice matters most.”
Then, on November 17, she showed us what she really thinks of resident voices.
In the middle of a packed special council meeting, Axon president Josh Isner publicly berated Borowsky for disobedience. Instead of standing her ground, Borowsky immediately let Isner march her upstairs to her private office.
When TAAZE’s attorney (the same citizens group who gathered 27,000 signatures to force a voter referendum on Axon’s original 1,900-unit monster) tried to join, Isner screamed “Get the f— out of here!” and appeared to threaten a lawsuit.
Forty minutes later they emerged with a backroom ‘compromise’: 1,200 high-density units,, zero deed restrictions, and the knife twist: Borowsky cast the swing 4-3 vote to:

  • waive Axon’s previously assured water supply commitments (in the middle of a 25-year drought),
  • grant Axon unprecedented VIP treatment to self-certify their buildings, a privilege never before granted in Scottsdale, and
  • permanently void the voter referendum you worked so hard to earn.

Yes, the same mayor who claims to respect the will of the voters just erased your referendum with a single vote, teaming up with Solange Whitehead, who has now sided with Axon and against Scottsdale residents at least seven separate times.

Other councilors were appalled about the secret meeting. Councilor Barry Graham called it “highly unusual… I’ve never seen anything like it.” Councilor Jan Dubauskas: “surprising and highly unusual.” Former Councilor Bob Littlefield was blunt that he believed Borowsky illegally created her own private executive session to cut a deal with the developer. (It’s worth mentioning that we know these details thanks to the reporting of the Scottsdale Progress.)
This is hypocrisy we can no longer ignore. Borowsky brags about meeting with TAAZE and “knowing what residents want,” yet the second Axon snaps its fingers she locks residents out and lets the corporation dictate the guest list, the water rules, and even whether your referendum lives or dies.
Scottsdale was played. Our mayor isn’t a mediator, she’s Axon’s closer.
The TAAZE lawsuit is still our lifeline. Support it. Show up. Speak out. And remember this moment in 2028 when Borowsky begs for four more years of the same smoke and mirrors.

Photo Credit: Fox 10

In a city where everything is photographed for Instagram, from your pink pasta to your overpriced mimosas, two alleged lovebirds forgot one crucial Scottsdale survival rule: assume you’re always on camera.

Last month, Corrisa K. Sucanick, 30, and Brian H. Morrow, 39, were arrested for what can only be described as the most romantically misguided burglary in Old Town history. The dynamic duo allegedly decided that Mon Cheri, that rose-covered, Instagram-worthy restaurant where bachelorette parties go to die happy, would make the perfect setting for their crime spree. And by crime spree, we mean stealing cash, liquor, and apparently, a moment.

According to Scottsdale PD, the pair broke into the restaurant near Indian School Road and Goldwater Boulevard in the early hours of Oct. 25, helping themselves to approximately $450 from the cash register, an iPhone, and a bottle of Bacardi rum. But here’s where things get… interesting. They also allegedly had sex inside a rose display designed for guests to take Instagram photos.

Yes, you read that correctly. The very same photo backdrop where countless bridal parties have posed with champagne flutes became the scene of what police delicately termed “alleged amorous activities.”

The restaurant’s owner, Lexi Caliskan, put it best when she told reporters, “They got caught in the moment, there’s roses everywhere, maybe it was kind of romantic but modern-day Bonnie and Clyde.” She also noted, with what we can only assume was exasperation, “Help.. they violated our roses.”

Now, here’s the thing about Mon Cheri: it’s decked out with roses and chandeliers, designed specifically to be an Instagrammable spot for girls’ brunches and celebrations. The entire establishment is basically a surveillance-friendly wonderland, complete with a ring-light adorned photo booth in the main inside dining area featuring a heart-shaped faux rose wall.

So naturally, the restaurant’s security cameras captured everything. And unlike most Old Town establishments where blurry footage leads nowhere, the suspects didn’t use facial coverings to conceal their identity. Because when you’re swept up in romance among the roses, who thinks about mundane details like surveillance technology?

Thanks to that crystal-clear footage and tips from the community (read: people who recognized them), Sucanick was arrested Nov. 3 in Scottsdale and Morrow was arrested the next day at a Motel 6 in Phoenix. Because of course the romantic getaway ended at a Motel 6.

Both face burglary charges, with Morrow also charged with possession of burglary tools. As for their passionate interlude? Police said that element did not meet the criteria for criminal prosecution. Small mercies.

The moral of this very Scottsdale story? If you’re going to commit crimes in Old Town, maybe pick a location that isn’t specifically designed for maximum photo documentation. And if you simply must get frisky during your felony, perhaps choose a venue that doesn’t literally market itself as an Instagram photo oasis.

After all, in Scottsdale, if it’s not documented on camera, did it even happen? Unfortunately for our amorous alleged burglars, it happened. And so did the arrests.

Robert Swagger. Photo Credit: KTAR

If you’re a regular reader of the Arizona Progress & Gazette, you’ve seen this story before. Scottsdale, with its affluent and aging population, has become notorious as both a haven for fraudsters and a prime hunting ground for scams. This week’s case is just the latest chapter in an unfortunately familiar narrative.

Robert Swagger, a Scottsdale man, has been ordered to pay $202,000 in restitution after admitting to securities fraud in a scheme that specifically targeted Christian investors. The setup was calculated and cynical. In 2019, Swagger approached members of the Young Presidents Organization Christian Fellowship Network, a group of Christian company presidents under age 45, with what appeared to be a faith-aligned investment opportunity in a streaming company featuring family-friendly content.

Swagger founded TRS PureFlix, LLC to manage these pooled investments, soliciting a minimum of $50,000 per investor through the YPOCFN message board. Between May and June 2019, he secured $202,000 from three investors. But here’s where the scheme unraveled: over $201,000 of that money was funneled to Swagger’s second company, TRS Companies, LLC, for “management fees” that should have totaled only $2,020. The funds were used to pay personal expenses, legal fees, credit cards, and membership dues; none of it went toward purchasing the promised promissory note.

Perhaps most damning? Swagger failed to disclose to investors that his securities license had been suspended in 2011 following accusations by a former employer that he hadn’t repaid a promissory note. A securities fraudster with a history of not repaying notes was selling promissory notes. The irony is almost poetic.

This case fits seamlessly into Scottsdale’s broader fraud problem. From cryptocurrency scams that have stolen $5 million from residents to massive Medicare fraud schemes, the city has become a magnet for financial crimes. The common thread? Wealthy, trusting residents make attractive targets.

So how do you protect yourself? Start with healthy skepticism. If someone approaches you with investment opportunities through affinity groups, whether religious, social, or professional, verify their credentials independently. Check securities licenses through FINRA’s BrokerCheck. Never invest based solely on shared values or group membership; fraudsters weaponize trust.

Ask hard questions about fees, and demand transparency about where your money actually goes. If management fees seem disproportionate to the investment amount, walk away. And perhaps most importantly, remember that faith-based or values-aligned investments aren’t immune to fraud; in fact, they’re often specifically targeted because of the built-in trust factor.

Swagger has pleaded guilty to federal wire fraud charges and faces sentencing in February 2026. But for Scottsdale investors, the lesson is clear: in a city where fraud has become disturbingly routine, due diligence isn’t optional…it’s essential.

Additional Legal Actions Anticipated After Majority Of Scottsdale City Council, Not Voters, Attempts To Greenlight Second Largest Multi-Family Housing Project In City History

(Scottsdale, Ariz.)  The fight against Axon’s assault on democracy and frustrated Scottsdale residents isn’t going away despite a recent 4 to 3 Scottsdale City Council decision to approve the second largest multifamily housing project (1,200 units) in city history as well as undermining efforts to challenge the controversial rezoning in court and with the scheduled city-wide vote in November 2026!

TAAAZE (Taxpayers Against Awful Apartment Zoning Exemptions) which collected nearly 30 thousand signatures last fall to challenge Axon’s apartments,  is still pursuing a lawsuit against SB1543 also known as the “Axon Bill” which put certain rezoning decisions beyond the reach of voter challenges, including last year’s lame duck Scottsdale City Council vote to approve 1,900 units near Hayden and the 101. The first hearing on the state law is set for late January. Scottsdale’s approval is based on the state law. If it is found unconstitutional, Scottsdale’s Axon approval is meaningless.

This year Scottsdale City Council Members Adam Kwasman, Mary Ann McAllen, Solange Whitehead, and Mayor Lisa Borowsky voted yes on a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Axon that approved 1,200 multifamily units. The city also agreed to abandon litigation against SB1543 as well as rescinding the previous zoning decision on Axon. And at a time of drought the council majority actually released Axon of its obligation to provide water for its project.

They claim Axon will build 600 apartments and 600 condominiums yet included no language in the MOU or secured Axon agreement otherwise, meaning without such language and agreement the mega Borowsky led approval is for 1,200 apartments.

Council Members Barry Graham, Jan Dubauskas, and Kathy Littlefield voted against the Axon apartment scheme.

TAAAZE has no plans to abandon the lawsuit against SB 1543 and is exploring other legal options to prevent Axon from building 1,200 multifamily units in Scottsdale, an area already dealing with massive traffic problems.

TAAAZE Chairman and former Scottsdale City Councilman Bob Littlefield said, “Axon can’t be trusted. But they can be challenged in court and at the ballot box despite any sweetheart deals they made with some members of the Scottsdale City Council or the Arizona Legislature. Let me make this clear, TAAAZE is unfazed. Our fight continues. Because if this is allowed to happen in one neighborhood, then no neighborhood in Arizona is safe from bad actors like Axon. They took away Scottsdale’s constitutional rights and rather than defend them with a council majority, actually submitted itself to the corporation that did so.”

Read More

By Supervisor Thomas Galvin

Hello Neighbors,

As we gather with loved ones this Thanksgiving, I’m reminded of how fortunate we are to live in a such a safe and thriving community. We own a special debt of gratitude to our veterans, sheriff’s deputies, and all our first responders who bravely serve and protect us. May this season bring peace, joy, and renewed appreciation for all we’ve accomplished together.


Judge Rules in Favor of Board of Supervisors in Elections Lawsuit!

A Maricopa County Superior Court judge recently rejected Recorder Justin Heap’s request to halt the Board of Supervisors audit of the county’s voter registration system and election technology. Election integrity is important to me. As Chairman, I promised in January that we would undertake a thorough, comprehensive review of our elections procedures, processes, and IT systems. I’m committed to transparency and am glad, but not surprised, we won this frivolous filing in the courts. You can click the picture below to read the full story from AZCentral. Read more from 12News, KJZZPhoenix New Times, and VoteBeat.

Read the full AZCentral story!


D2 Highlights


My Joint Statement with Vice Chair Brophy McGee on Melendres Filing

Since joining the Board of Supervisors, I have remained committed to protecting Maricopa County taxpayers. I have repeatedly raised concerns about the lengthy and costly federal oversight of the Sheriff’s office. In a court filing on Friday, November 22, we outlined how the County’s budgeting policies are not subject to federal jurisdiction. Instead, our budgeting policies are accountable to YOU, the County taxpayers.

Read the Full Statement

Read the full joint statement here!


Thanking Our Emergency Management Heroes!

When I think of what I am grateful for this year, I find myself especially thankful for the great men and women of our Maricopa County Emergency Management Department. This team has gone above and beyond during the significant storms our region faced this fall.

Please click the picture below to enjoy a video highlighting the work of this exceptional team!

Thank you, Maricopa County Department of Emergency Management!


Honoring Our Veterans

I was honored to present our two highly decorated speakers for this year’s Maricopa County Veteran’s Day Ceremony. Detective Robert Lopez had a distinguished military service career before joining the Tempe Police Department. Lt. Ryan Neville called the military a family business before joining the Sheriff’s Office. I thank both these gentlemen, and all our veterans, for their selfless and courageous service.

It was a pleasure to speak to my fellow County employees at this year's Veteran's Day Ceremony!


Thank you, Lt. Ryan Neville (left) and Detective Robert Lopez (right) of the Tempe Police Department for speaking at our Veterans Day Ceremony!


Commemorating the New Southeast Juvenile Building Grand Opening

It was an honor to celebrate the opening of the much-improved Maricopa County Southeast Juvenile Justice Facility. The renovation and enhancements of the more than 235,000 square foot facility came in $600,000 under budget! Congratulations to Presiding Judge Pamela Gates and Juvenile Presiding Judge Lori Bustamante. The Board of Supervisors is proud to approve the funding for this worthy project!

Thank you, Beck (left), Juvenile Presiding Judge Bustamante (center), and Presiding Judge Gates (right)!


Congratulations to all who played a role in bringing this new building to life!


Speaking at the Arizona Chamber Board Meeting

This month, I spoke at the Arizona Chamber of Commerce’s Board Meeting. I was proud to let these local leaders know that Maricopa County is being run like the efficient and successful business it is!

Thank you to the Arizona Chamber for having me!


Arcadia Osborn Neighborhood Association Fall Festival

It was wonderful meeting so many of you at the Arcadia Osborn Neighborhood Association Fall Festival! The event was full of great food, fun activities, and valuable resources for our community to explore.

It was great enjoying our fall weather and meeting so many of you!


D2 is Open for Business!


Congratulations, Creative Hands Cuisine!

This month, Michele from our District 2 office attended the grand opening of Creative Hands Cuisine in Fountain Hills!


It's Christmas Season in Scottsdale!

Santa has come to town in Scottsdale! This month, Taylor from our District 2 office joined a recent Scottsdale Chamber event where Santa himself cut the ribbon on the start of his season as the official “Scottsdale Santa.”


Congratulations to TC Eggington!

Congratulations to Mesa’s T.C. Eggington’s Brunchery for celebrating 40 years in business! Michele and Taylor from our office attended the celebration!


In the News


November Pup-date with Paw-litics!

Meet Butterfly! This energetic pup was my latest co-host on Paw-litics, my ongoing video series designed to keep you up to date with what’s going on at the County, while showing off one of the adoptable dogs in our County shelters. Click the picture below to watch the latest video!

I had a great time filming Paw-litics with my co-host, Butterfly!


My First Time on the Upfront Planning Podcast!

It was great to join the Upfront Planning Podcast to discuss business development, affordable housing, and so much more. Thank you to host, Jessica Sarkissian for having me!

In the studio with the Upfront Planning Podcast!


¡Gracias por invitarme, Univision!

Thank you for having me, Univision! I had a wonderful time joining host, Heidi Renpenning, for Al Punto to discuss the latest news at Maricopa County.

¡Gracias por invitarme, Univision!


Things to do in District 2!


“Lights of Love” Returns to the East Valley!

If you’re looking for some holiday cheer this Christmas Season, Sunshine Acres in Mesa is hosting a drive-thru Christmas Lights display. This free, festive lights display is fun for the whole family!

Lights of Love is back!


Nonprofit Spotlight


United Food Bank

For more than 40 years, United Food Bank has been a beacon of hope for those experiencing hunger in Arizona. United Food Bank covers a service area of nearly 20,000 square miles, including some of the most remote parts of our state. This Mesa-based food bank is a lifeline for those working to make ends meet and keep their families fed.

United Food Bank

Learn more about United Food Bank here!


What to Chew in District 2


Local Favorite: Greek Café Mix

Cafe Mix is a family-friendly, locally owned Greek restaurant in Apache Junction. Check out a varies of favorites including gyros, salads, kabobs, baba ghanoush, and spanakopita. Enjoy the family-friendly atmosphere and fun twists on classic flavors at this AJ favorite!

Greek Café Mix

Check out Café Mix!

What to Chew in District 2 Form

District 2 is on a mission to spotlight the district’s tastiest food. Whether you’re a new restaurant, a food truck, or a local staple that’s been around forever, please fill out the below form so we can follow up with you about potentially showcasing your story in our newsletter.

By Brian C. Anderson, reposted from City Journal

Three decades ago, the visionary social thinker Peter Huber published Orwell’s Revenge, a book that turned one of the twentieth century’s most haunting political parables on its head. Where George Orwell imagined a future of total information control, Huber saw the opposite: a world where digital technology shattered centralized authority. In 1984, the Ministry of Truth could rewrite history because it monopolized the tools of communication. But in the digital age, Huber argued, the networked computer would scatter those tools across society, producing an unruly democracy of voices. The Internet, he predicted, would not empower “Big Brother” but millions of “little brothers”—individuals able to report and argue and publish. What once seemed a one-way flow of information from elite institutions to a passive public was becoming a many-to-many conversation. The gatekeepers were being evicted by the code.

This technological revolution would have profound cultural consequences. As Huber memorably put it, “Better communicating machines produce more—not less—communication, more—not less—free expression, more—not less—political involvement, more—not less—freedom of thought.” The people who controlled legacy newsrooms—highly educated and overwhelmingly left-leaning—had long exercised a disproportionate power to define what counted as respectable opinion. When those gatekeepers lost influence, new kinds of voices surged through. In a book published in 2005, I described the early energies of this revolt, chronicling how talk radio, cable news, and the early Internet—all unleashed by the mutations in communications technology—disrupted liberal cultural authority. Right-of-center ideas and perspectives suddenly found much wider distribution.

Read the full piece here

Photo Credit: Trip Advisor

So, big news if you’re a Saturday market regular: the Old Town Scottsdale Farmers Market is packing up and heading to the city hall parking lot when the 2026-27 season kicks off. After more than a decade at the First Street and Brown Avenue parking garage, change is coming, and honestly, people have feelings about it.

Let’s start with the good news, because there is some. The city is expanding the current parking structure, which is why the market has to move in the first place. More parking in Old Town isn’t exactly a bad thing, right? And the market isn’t disappearing; it’s just relocating. City Manager Greg Caton promises it’ll stay close to Old Town’s heart while giving vendors and visitors the space they need.

Plus, the new location at city hall means better infrastructure support. We’re talking about organized vendor parking, improved wayfinding, and facilities designed to accommodate what’s become one of Scottsdale’s most beloved Saturday traditions.

Now for the reality check. If you’ve been going to this market for years, you know location matters…a lot. Some longtime customers have already raised concerns about whether the city hall spot will have the same foot traffic and Old Town charm. One vendor put it bluntly during city council discussions: his customers don’t want to trek to a city hall parking lot.

There’s also the question of what this means for Old Town retail. When you move a major weekend attraction that brings hundreds of people into the area, you’re potentially shifting foot traffic patterns that local businesses have relied on for over a decade. And let’s be real: a city hall parking lot doesn’t have quite the same vibe as the heart of Old Town.

The bottom line? The market is staying in Scottsdale, which is what matters most. But this move represents a shift in how we experience one of our community’s favorite weekend traditions, and it’s fair to have mixed feelings about that.

By Tammy Caputi

The Council is amending the Rules of Procedure on December 2. The justification is to “improve transparency, civility, decorum and public participation.” The changes are “intended to make our meetings more efficient, civil, and legally sound.

REALLY?

Here are the proposed changes:

  • Reduce public comment periods from two to one.
  • Move public comments from the beginning of the meeting to the end.
  • Reduce speaker time from three minutes to two minutes.
  • Forbid the use of city audio visual equipment to play recordings.
  • Require two weeks advance notice to consider citizen petitions.

How on earth does this “improve public participation”? Under these new rules, this very topic would be outside the scope of a citizen petition since it was snuck in just before the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.

So much for the “resident-friendly” council.

The Killers

The WM Phoenix Open has weathered its share of storms this year, but the tournament’s ability to pull off major entertainment coups proves it remains one of golf’s most formidable events.

Yes, the Scottsdale spectacle has faced legitimate criticism. From concerns about overcrowding and unruly fan behavior to questions about whether the party atmosphere overshadows the actual golf, the WM Open has given its detractors plenty of ammunition. The tournament has long walked a tightrope between raucous entertainment and professional sport, and that balance hasn’t always held steady.

But here’s the thing about juggernauts: they keep rolling forward.

Case in point? The Killers will be performing at the legendary Bird’s Nest, the nightly party venue that has become as much a part of the WM Open’s identity as the stadium atmosphere at the 16th hole. Landing a band of The Killers’ caliber isn’t just impressive…it’s a statement. We’re talking about one of the biggest rock acts of the past two decades, a band that headlines major festivals and sells out arenas worldwide. Their setlist alone could power an entire music festival.

The Bird’s Nest has hosted impressive lineups before, but The Killers represent something different. This isn’t just getting a popular band; it’s securing legitimate headliner talent that transcends the golf world and positions the WM Open as a premier entertainment destination, not just a sporting event. When fans can watch world-class golf during the day and then catch “Mr. Brightside” and “Somebody Told Me” at night, the value proposition becomes undeniable.

Critics may grumble about the tournament’s focus on spectacle, but the WM Open has found a formula that works spectacularly well. It consistently draws massive crowds, generates enormous charitable donations, and now offers entertainment that rivals standalone music festivals.

The controversies won’t disappear, and the tournament should continue addressing legitimate concerns. But with moves like bringing in The Killers, the WM Open proves it’s not just surviving its challenges—it’s thriving despite them, remaining an unstoppable force in professional golf.

By Alexander Lomax

Photo Credit: Arizona PBS

Facing an onslaught of negativity for crafting a capitulation rather than a compromise with Axon over its massive apartment plan on Monday night, Mayor Lisa Borowsky sent out the press release below.

After getting booed yesterday at the Palo Verde Republican Women’s meeting I get the attempt at spin.

Unfortunately, our reliable sources are able to debunk much of the Mayor’s diatribe.

Lie #1:  She stated a California union funded the referendum drive.  Simply not true.   One need only look at publicly available campaign finance reports which show the union in question contributing about 6% of the signatures and funds.  The Mayor knows yet continues to perpetuate a falsehood.

Lie #2:  She engineered a settlement with “600 apartments and 600 condominiums.”  Yet, the Mayor failed to include any language – and continues to refuse to do so – that would ensure condominiums.  Her deal effectively allows 1,200 apartments.

Lie #3: Basically everything else in the press release, according to sources.

Notably, the Mayor failed to note new special favors exempting Axon from water pledges previously agreed to even though Scottsdale is facing severe problems because of drought and its reliance on Colorado River water or that, for the first time in city history, is allowing a developer (Axon) to police itself during construction.  She also, for the first time in history, unilaterally eliminated the constitutional voting rights of citizens.

The Mayor could have ended this issue with a smart, reasonable compromise.  She failed, miserably.  Fix the problems Mayor rather than channel Pinocchio.  You actually have the ability to do so.

Meanwhile the issue remains very much alive because the state law underpinning the Scottsdale scheme remains the subject of compelling litigation, with more litigation on other fronts coming, sources also confirm.

Her press release:

The Taxpayers Against Awful Apartment Zoning Exemptions (“TAAAZE”) committee, led by former Councilman Bob Littlefield, ran the out-of-state, union-funded Axon referendum. Of the about 27,000 signatures gathered, a total of 25,000 Scottsdale voter signatures were paid for by a California labor union.

Just as our U.S. Constitution guarantees a defendant the right to a speedy trial, in this instance, Axon was told by a majority of my council colleagues, their trial by election would be delayed two years, set in November 2026.

Axon appealed the delay to the Arizona Legislature, which resulted in Senate Bill 1543 (“the Axon bill”) being passed and signed by the Governor. Axon “won” an exception to local zoning control, which effectively made our votes in the referendum election moot.

However, the Axon bill had defects that make it susceptible to constitutional legal challenges. If the election was held before the legislature fixed those issues, it would have made SB 1543 meaningless. Instead, the legislature had plenty of time to override our right to have a meaningful vote.

In July, I asked the City Council to hold the referendum election at the next available date, which would have been November 2025. Councilmembers Dubauskas, Graham and Littlefield refused, and they were successful in blocking a timely election set earlier this month — at de minimis cost to the city.

Again, in October, I asked the City Council to hold an election at the next available date, which would have been March 2026. Again, those same Councilmembers refused to listen to reason and said, “no.”

Mr. Littefield has been quoted as saying, “I always said we need to let people vote on the issue,” which is a curious comment from Bob because his political allies on City Council repeatedly denied my requests to hold an early election. What is even more curious is Bob telling a colleague the reason for delaying the election until November 2026 was to get himself and Councilman Graham re-elected.

Accordingly, we were left with only two choices:

  1. File a lawsuit against the flawed Axon legislation, only to have Axon go back to the legislature to fix SB1543, neutering TAAAZE’s and the City’s legal claims and further nullifying the referendum election, leaving Axon free to build 2,000 apartments or more; or
  2. Strike a compromise to reduce the number of units and project density.

I promised the voters to oppose high-density apartments. In keeping with my promise, I negotiated a major reduction of density, down from 2,000 apartments to 600 apartments and 600 condominiums. Importantly, TAAAZE representatives agreed to resolve the entire dispute if Axon agreed to build 500 apartments and 1,000 condos. In the end, my negotiations with Axon resulted in a much lower overall density than TAAAZE’s last demand.

Isn’t it time to end the political gamesmanship and jockeying?

Delaying the election cost us our right to vote on the Axon project and resulted in the city being stuck with SB 1543. If we are faced with another referendum, let’s have the election right away and not make the voters wait and risk more legislative interference.

Photo Credit: Scottsdale Progress

This past week brought with it unfortunate news for the city of Scottsdale; that it has lost one of its greatest champions. Bill Walton, the landscape architect and former city councilman whose vision transformed a flood-prone marsh into one of America’s most celebrated urban greenbelts, passed away on November 3 at the age of 95.

Walton arrived in Scottsdale in 1963, fresh from Iowa State University, ready to apply his landscape architecture training to the growing desert community. What he found was a city divided by “The Slough”: a brush-choked gash that regularly flooded, threatening homes and businesses. Where others saw an engineering problem requiring concrete channels, Walton saw possibility.

It began with a letter to the editor, a simple inquiry about creating something comparable to New York’s Central Park. That night, two city council members knocked on his door at 10 p.m., asking if he’d chair a committee to explore the idea. It may have been Scottsdale’s most consequential cold call.

What followed was decades of persistence. Walton faced skepticism from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, multiple failed bond proposals, and agencies that deemed his greenbelt concept too expensive. But after a devastating 1972 flood changed public opinion, voters approved funding by a 7-1 margin. When Silverado Golf Course opened in 1999, the Indian Bend Wash Greenbelt was complete; providing over 63,000 residents within walking distance access to parks, golf courses, lakes, and paths.

The project earned recognition as one of the nation’s top engineering feats and was featured in international exhibitions. But Walton’s legacy extended far beyond the greenbelt. He helped develop TPC Scottsdale and bring the Phoenix Open to the city, negotiated with the PGA and federal government to create attractions generating millions in tax revenue, and worked to revitalize the McDowell corridor.

Jim Bruner, who served alongside Walton on the council despite their opposing political philosophies, captured his colleague’s essence perfectly: “Bill was a visionary, a wonderful person, and an excellent council member. Despite being on opposite sides of the political spectrum, we collaborated effectively. I had immense respect for him and valued all his contributions to our city.”

Mayor Herb Drinkwater called Walton “an institution” at his 1992 retirement party, recognizing nearly three decades of community service. Attorney Randy Nussbaum later observed that Walton was “one of the reasons Scottsdale is envied by Southwest cities.”

Bill Walton’s Scottsdale is the one we enjoy today: a city where nature and urban development coexist, where flooding gave way to recreation, and where one person’s vision became a community’s treasure. His legacy flows through every path along the greenbelt, every round of golf at TPC, and every resident who calls this remarkable desert city home.

By Councilwoman Jan Dubauskas

You elect us to make tough votes. You elect us to protect Scottsdale and keep Scottsdale special. You elect us to fight for your constitutional rights.

You did not elect us to make excuses or to bow to corporate interests.

Over the past year, you have sent us thousands of emails, asking, begging, pleading with Council to side with the residents. You asked us to protect your city and your voice.

On Monday, Councilman Graham, Councilwoman Littlefield and I stood firmly together. We put you first and fought for your constitutional right of referendum to vote on the Axon project. 

Unfortunately, Borowsky, Whitehead, Kwasman, and McAllen voted against you and in favor of a deal with Axon. Read here.

Here’s the Borowsky, Whitehead, Kwasman, McAllen deal:

1) 1,200 housing units. While the contract says 600 apartments and 600 condos, without a voluntary deed restriction from Axon, that split is not legally enforceable by the city. Axon can build 1,200 apartments.

2) No citizen referendum. Nearly 27,000 concerned residents signed a petition to put the Axon project on the ballot and it was certified by the city. The resident referendum is canceled.

3) No lawsuit. The city of Scottsdale will not sue the state of Arizona over the Axon bill SB1543. The city of Scottsdale will not defend your constitutional right to referendum.

4) Self-Certification. Axon will be the first company in the history of the city of Scottsdale to self-certify that its building meets city code.

5) No Water. Axon will provide no additional water to cover its use.

Councilwoman Littlefield, Councilman Graham and I voted to defend Scottsdale and protect your right to vote on this important project.

Yet, I am a big fan of Axon’s products, it’s upgraded headquarters, and the project’s boutique hotel. However, 1,200 units are just too many. Our job is to represent YOU. I promised to always remember you – and to put you first.

Promises Made, Promises Kept
Although disappointed in this outcome, I remain very proud to stand and fight for Scottsdale with Councilwoman Littlefield and Councilman Graham.

By Alexander Lomax

I apparently couldn’t go more than a week without some reactionary bullocks regarding Scottsdale and Charlie Kirk came across my screen. Literally just last week I wrote this piece where I questioned why Scottsdale officials were considering a memorial for Charlie Kirk. And just like Isaac Newton said, with every action comes an equal and opposite reaction.

Unfortunately that equal but opposite reaction manifested itself in the strangest of ways: hundreds of people signed a petition to attempt to eliminate Turning Point USA clubs in the Scottsdale Unified School District (Turning Point USA was the organization that Kirk founded). Yes, let’s fight the things we don’t like by trying to ban them as we unironically rail against conservative politicians attempting to ban some books.

The petition talks about the organization as one that “promote(s) hate, division, or discrimination under the guise of ‘religious’ or ‘political’ values.” And yet again, the political left loses the plot completely.

And let me be clear…Charlie Kirk said some fairly disagreeable stuff. That was his job as a provocateur. He debated, he provoked a response. And in the modern age where everything is somewhere on the internet, 100% of the people who are in the political influencing industry have said some gross things. Right or left, all you need to do is ask ChatGPT for the worst things they’ve ever said. This is in the same time period where one of the most popular progressive influencers, Hasan Piker, is accused of shocking his dog on camera.

These people are not heroes. And this goes for everyone in the comments who deifies Kirk and talks about what a godly man he was. You didn’t know him. You didn’t know his heart. In reality he probably wasn’t a good person because EXTREMELY few people whose careers are in political influencing are truly good people. It’s the wrong line of work for the good.

But that’s not the point. This is another example of a disturbing tendency from those on the left over the last decade plus: if they don’t like something they would rather silence it. They don’t want to offer a better argument. They will liken any effort to have a free exchange of ideas with a conservative as “platforming” “dangerous ideas”. The same brain trust that wouldn’t let Kamala Harris go on the Joe Rogan podcast because she would be “platforming right-wingers” and instead put her in front of a friendly progressive audience would simply prefer that the other side didn’t exist.

While I may lean more to the left than the right nationally, I’ve never known a conservative that wouldn’t talk to a liberal because of their beliefs. But I have known many on the left who cut conservatives out of their lives because they liked Trump.

The political left needs to grow the hell up. Develop a better argument instead of trying to silence everyone. Voters have made it clear that they’re not buying your attempts to shut everyone up. If you don’t like free speech, perhaps North Korea or Russia are more to your liking.

2020 Scrum


By Mary Manross, Former Scottsdale Mayor and Chairwoman for Vote YES YES Scottsdale PAC
and Carla, Preserve Pioneer and Campaign Coordinator for Vote YES YES Scottsdale PAC

In most campaigns there are winners and losers. Not when it comes to the passage of Propositions 490 and 491 in Scottsdale which happened on November 5th. We believe everyone in Scottsdale wins.

Proposition 490 will help revitalize and maintain Scottsdale’s parks, beginning with the Indian Bend Wash Greenbelt, and will provide ongoing care and protection for the McDowell Sonoran Preserve.  It will provide funding to prevent and fight fires in and around the Preserve, and funds for increased police rangers for the parks and the Preserve.

Almost sixty years ago Scottsdale had the wisdom and foresight to create the Greenbelt and, thirty years ago, to create the McDowell Sonoran Preserve. They are two of Scottsdale’s greatest decisions and treasures. That wisdom and foresight are still with us today as evidenced by this vote.

Proposition 490 contains legal safeguards to ensure the money is properly spent. And we think these safeguards, and the benefits of the measure will win over many who voted no and maybe even some critics. Now that the voters of Scottsdale have spoken overwhelmingly in support of Proposition 490, we look forward to working with the new Mayor and Council to see that it is implemented properly and responsibly.Read More

By Carla (Carla), Preserve Pioneer

This year Scottsdale was fortunate when it came to wildfires. Next year we might not be so lucky.

As every summer gets hotter and drier, nature and human caused fires are a fact of life in Scottsdale and our Preserve. Thanks to the quick response and hard work of our Firefighters  – plus a little luck with wind direction  – we have avoided a catastrophic fire this year.

But next year, unless Propositions 490 & 491 pass, we won’t have as many tools to help prevent fires.

Year round our Fire Department does excellent outreach work with developments in Northern Scottsdale to address not planting invasive species and removing fire loads. They also work with the Arizona Department of Forestry and Fire Management to get grants which provide for wildfire prevention. Specifically invasive plant removal and preventative measures along our Preserve boundary and major roadways.

But Scottsdale did NOT get a grant to fund this work in 2025!

Proposition 490 would add Fire Department funding to provide quicker response times; increased Fire prevention programs; a second Technical Rescue Team; and additional resources to better protect you and your neighborhoods.

Proposition 491 – which is not a tax increase or budget override  – would allow Scottsdale to spend the money it already collects on programs and services that residents want and need. Without its passage, city services will face cutbacks, including in public safety.

Please join the Firefighters, who dedicate their lives to protecting you,  in voting YES-YES on Props 490 and 491. It’s critical to Scottsdale’s safety and future quality of life.

Carla (Carla), Preserve Pioneer

Data Orbital, in conjunction with AZ Free News, is pleased to announce the results of its latest statewide, live caller survey of likely General Election Voters. The survey was conducted from September 7th 2024 – September 9th 2024. The survey measured support for candidates in Arizona’s Presidential contest. This survey was sponsored by AZ Free News.

For President, the Democratic candidate Vice President Kamala Harris trails Republican former President Donald Trump by a slim 46.0% to 46.2% margin. 7.7% reported as being undecided or refused the question.

Speaking with AZ Free News about the Presidential race, George Khalaf, President of Data Orbital, stated “That 7.7% undecided number, I would say, is going to be one of two things: 1.) Either individuals that are saying that they are likely to vote but don’t end up voting or 2.) People that really are truly undecided. But I would be shocked if the true undecided number is in the high single digits”. Khalaf goes on to explain, “I would guess that right now, the true percentage of people that are undecided is maybe one or two percent, if that. This is a high-profile race and so most people have made up their minds. But I think a portion of people that are undecided likely will not end up making a decision on November 5th”.

By Jeanne Beasley
Candidate for Scottsdale School Board

As students return to school this week, let’s consider what we can do to help support and strengthen our local public schools. I am running for a seat on the Scottsdale Unified School Board on November 5, alongside Gretchen Jacobs and Drew Hassler, to serve our community positively.

We are parents, professionals, and community leaders who have had students in our Scottsdale schools and believe that strong communities should have strong public schools. Families shouldn’t have to look elsewhere for the excellent academic opportunities and well-rounded extracurricular experiences they desire for their children.

Our campaign, “Just Be Honest,” will bring a new era of transparency, accountability, and integrity to SUSD. Our mission is to ensure that every decision made is in the best interest of our students, families, and teachers.Read More

With just five days remaining until Arizona’s 2024 primary election, let’s take a closer look at how Republicans and Democrats are performing across the state.

Focusing first on the Republicans, a total of 1,156,580 GOP ballots have been requested. Of these, 1,089,498 are from registered Republicans and 67,082 from Independents. These numbers surpass the total requests from both 2020 and 2022, which were 1,035,288 and 1,059,348, respectively. Currently, Republicans have a 32.7% ballot return rate, while Independents have a 49.2% return rate, resulting in an overall return rate of 33.7%.

At this stage in the election, GOP ballot returns across the state are ahead of 2022 but are behind 2020. In 2020, returns at this time were 426,571, compared to 375,714 in 2022. So far in 2024, a total of 389,458 GOP ballots have been returned.

Now looking at the Democratic side, total ballot requests stand at 1,063,267, with 1,008,909 from Democrats and 54,358 from Independents. This exceeds the totals from both 2020, which had 1,044,288 requests, and 2022, which had 1,041,271 requests. Democrats are returning their ballots at a 29.4% rate, while Independents are returning at a 48.9% rate, resulting in an overall return rate of 30.4%

At this stage in the cycle, Democratic returns are lagging behind both 2020 and 2022. In 2020, Democratic returns were 439,383, and in 2022 they were 368,745. Both figures are notably higher than the current returns in 2024, which stand at 322,984.