By Vanessa Rogers
The Nov. 3 ballots are barely counted, yet Scottsdale’s next council race is already taking shape. Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita are on track to win the two remaining seats, giving the city’s conservative bloc a majority. However, the fight to turn that into a true mandate comes in 2028.
Four seats will be on that ballot: the mayor’s, plus those held by Jan Dubauskas, Adam Kwasman and Maryann McAllen. However, there is strong speculation that Dubauskas may run for Mayor, and Kwasman reportedly is considering a run for higher office, meaning that there may be one or two open seats currently held by conservatives.
Two names keep surfacing in conservative circles. One is a familiar face, whose employer got a call from Axon. The other is a genuine wild card.
The Math After January
When the new council is seated, Graham, Ugenti-Rita and Dubauskas form a reliable three-vote bloc. All three opposed the Axon compromise and have stood together on development. Still, three votes win nothing on a seven-member council.
Kwasman is a conservative, but he joined the 4-3 majority that approved Axon’s 1,200-unit plan. Mayor Lisa Borowsky, who brokered that final compromise, cast the deciding vote. That vote was largely an outlier and otherwise has been primarily on the side of the conservative bloc of Graham, Littlefield and Dubauskas, including on the appointment and ongoing support of City Manager Greg Caton. McAllen and Solange Whitehead both having politics that are considered left-leaning, and both voted in favor of Axon’s plans.
In some ways, 2028 decides whether the conservative bloc governs outright or keeps hunting for a fourth vote.
Christian Serena: The Commissioner Who Wouldn’t Fold

APG readers know this story well. In January 2024, Serena was the lone Planning Commission vote against giving Axon more time. Soon after, someone from Axon called his employer, Merrill Lynch. The city attorney then sent the company a sharp letter. Serena did not back down.
Since then, he has stayed in the fight. He assisted Graham’s 2026 campaign and has written guest editorials for this publication. He is also a Forbes-ranked wealth advisor and a Scottsdale native with a long record of civic engagement. In fact, few potential candidates arrive with a cleaner origin story. Voters tend to remember who stood up when it cost something.
Tommy Plato: The Old Town Wild Card

Tommy Plato. Photo Credit: Arizona Foothill Magazine
Plato is a different kind of prospect. He owns The Ends on Stetson Drive, after years running Second Story Liquor Bar and Kazimierz. His restaurant became Arizona’s first verified seed-oil-free kitchen. He was recently a top sponsor with a speaking role at Experience Scottsdale’s annual conclave.
Politically, however, he is less defined, but there are strong clues, most notably that he hosted the victory party for Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita. In January, he addressed the council in support of the Downtown Task Force. That puts him squarely in Old Town’s long-running arguments over parking, marketing and the farmers market. Downtown merchants rarely get a champion on the dais. Plato could be one.
Of course, a wild card cuts both ways. He has no voting record, no campaign history and no stated position on Axon. Voters will want those answers early. But in a city where tourism is so important a restaurateur could be a compelling recipe.
What It Means
The political calculus gets tricky, since we don’t yet know how many incumbents will be running for re-election, nor do we know of any potential left-leaning candidates who will make a run to join McAllen. Suppose Serena and Plato both ran, the conservative bloc will be strengthened (or at least hold), and since Axon picked a fight with Serena they would have created an enemy that is now on council. That is a big if, of course. Incumbents rarely go quietly unless they choose to, and Axon’s allies have already shown they will spend.
Nonetheless, the 2028 race already has its storylines. One candidate earned his reputation by refusing to fold. The other may have to earn his from scratch.
Discover more from Arizona Progress Gazette
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

