Another Scottsdale STR Party, Another Round of Gunfire

Scottsdale has heard this story before. Last month, a party at a south Scottsdale short-term rental ended with 15 to 20 shots fired from the porch, yard and street. Bullets hit nearby homes. One lodged in the wall of a house where an infant was sleeping.

On Nov. 9, police arrested an 18-year-old Apache Junction man on suspicion of endangerment, disorderly conduct and illegally firing a gun. His brother’s name was on the rental contract. Detectives are still looking for others involved. Meanwhile, the city says it has a new way to seek a license suspension in extreme cases like this one.

Not a Neighborhood Problem Until It Was

Papago Drive near 72nd Place is a quiet residential street. Residents there did not invite a crowd with handguns and a rifle. Instead, an unstaffed rental brought one in for the night. Police say Ring footage showed people firing toward another group in the roadway. At least seven neighbors called 911.

That is the core problem with STRs. They drop hotel-style turnover into neighborhoods without a hotel’s staff, security or accountability. Moreover, the people who pay the price never signed the contract.

A Pattern, Not an Outlier

We covered this in May, when gunfire near the Maya condominiums tied back to a rental party in a complex dominated by STRs. Since then, the numbers have only grown. Between January and August, Scottsdale police logged 665 calls for service at short-term rentals. Of those, 238 came in just three summer months. The city now has nearly 3,000 active rental licenses.

STR location map in Scottsdale, from Reddit

To its credit, the city has responded. In June, the council unanimously defined “event center” in city code, closing a loophole that let party houses slip through. A team drawn from several departments now handles complaints and licensing. Still, fines totaled about $9,000 in August. For an operator charging premium nightly rates, that is just a cost of doing business.

Front and Center for the New Council

The timing of this is not insignificant. In January, Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita join a council where conservatives will hold real sway. Graham has been blunt, saying STRs “have destroyed many of our neighborhoods and our streets.” After his reelection, he listed cracking down on rental bad actors among his priorities. As a state lawmaker, Ugenti-Rita reportedly voted against the 2016 law that stripped cities of most of their power over STRs.

However, state law still limits what any council can do. The real test is whether this majority pushes the Legislature harder and uses every local tool it has, license suspensions included.

Neighbors on Papago Drive are not asking for a white paper. They want to know why a bullet ended up in a home where a baby was sleeping. The new council should have an answer.


Discover more from Arizona Progress Gazette

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.