Just Desserts: The Lawmaker Who Silenced Scottsdale Voters Is Losing His Own Seat

by Ronald Sampson

In 2025, more than 26,000 Scottsdale residents signed petitions to put Axon’s apartment-heavy headquarters plan to a public vote. They never got that vote. State Rep. Tony Rivero, a Peoria Republican, ran the bill that canceled it, and he admitted Axon brought it to him. Now his own voters are having their say.

With most ballots counted, Rivero is in third place for Legislative District 27’s two House seats. Democrat Deborah Howard has already been declared a winner. Fellow Republican Lisa Fink holds the second seat by 313 votes. If that holds, and at this point it is highly likely to, Rivero is out.

A District Built for Him

This is not a swing seat. As of July, LD27 had 49,530 active Republican voters and 34,905 Democrats. That is a registration edge of nearly 15,000 voters, or about 11 points. In 2024, Rivero cruised to reelection, finishing roughly 5,400 votes ahead of Howard.

This time, Howard leads him by more than 6,700 votes. Even his own running mate outpolled him. Fink won about 31.3% of the vote to Rivero’s 31.0%. When the Republican on your own slate beats you in a district this red, it is hard to blame the environment alone.

The Bill That Followed Him

Rivero insisted SB 1543 was “not specific to Axon.” Yet he could not name another project it would apply to. He also suggested Scottsdale’s leaders had failed the company, as if the voters who signed those petitions were the problem.

Meanwhile, Scottsdale’s own Republican lawmakers fought him. Joseph Chaplik and Alexander Kolodin warned the bill set a dangerous precedent by overriding citizens who had followed the rules. They were right. A legislator from Peoria decided Scottsdale voters could not be trusted with a decision about Scottsdale.

Another Loss for Axon

More than a single anecdote, this is another data point in a clear pattern. Axon’s allies spent heavily this year to beat Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita, and both won. Now the lawmaker who carried Axon’s water at the Capitol may be heading home too.

It is worth noting that the count is not final. Arizona election rules dictate that margins under 0.5% trigger an automatic recount, so the votes are likely to be recounted. That said, 314 votes in a legislative district are not found within the couch cushions. The takeaway is nearly certain: voters in a solidly Republican district looked at their incumbent and moved on.

Scottsdale residents were denied their vote on Axon. Some of them may take quiet satisfaction that Rivero’s constituents got theirs.


Discover more from Arizona Progress Gazette

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.