Zubia and Graham Trade Water Visions in First Council Debate

By Vanessa Rogers

Scottsdale voters got their first side-by-side look at the council race this week as three candidates are competing for two seats. Early voting begins next week. The first of two debates touched on water, tourism, short-term rentals and public safety.

Water Takes Center Stage

Raoul Zubia, a lifelong Scottsdale resident, called water the top issue he hears from voters. He said he is running to “secure our water.” He also said he wants City Hall to be calmer and more focused on residents.

Incumbent Barry Graham, who also grew up in Scottsdale, agreed that water security is a high priority. However, the two men framed it differently. Graham said the supply is secure today but could be at risk if the city keeps giving it away to large apartment developers.

Development and Neighborhoods

Graham highlighted his record of protecting neighborhoods and his opposition to short-term rentals. He described his approach to growth as stopping harmful overdevelopment. Zubia, for his part, returned to his call for a council that puts citizens first.

Both messages are easy to understand. Voters will decide which one matches the city they want.

The Empty Podium

Organizers invited the third candidate, Michelle Ugenti-Rita, to the debate. They said she was unable to attend. As a result, voters heard from only two of the three contenders.

Her positions will need another venue. A second debate is set for Oct. 19, and attendance requires advance registration through the Scottsdale Chamber of Commerce. Whether all three candidates share a stage then remains to be seen.

A Lighter Moment

The evening was not entirely serious. Candidates fielded questions about their favorite animals, and Zubia picked the Labrador retriever. He has two at home. Graham went with zebras.

Karaoke came up as well. Zubia admitted he does not sing, though he offered “Celebrate” as his pick. Graham went with “Sweet Caroline.” Fortunately for everyone, nobody had to perform.

What Comes Next

With ballots about to go out, there is still time to do homework. Watch the second debate, read candidate materials, and compare answers on water and development. In a race this close to home, every voter has a say.