By Councilwoman Kathy Littlefield and Former Councilman Bob Littlefield
Dear Friends,
By now most of you will have heard that Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita were elected to the two open seats on the Scottsdale City Council, defeating overdevelopment candidate Raoul Zubia. This is good news for Scottsdale residents and bad news for the special interests who seek to exploit Scottsdale’s special character and high quality of life for their own selfish gain.
Many have expressed surprise that Graham and Ugenti-Rita, both registered Republicans, were able to defeat Raoul Zubia, a registered Democrat, in the face of the “blue wave” of Democrat victories that swept the state and national elections. While being Republicans didn’t hurt, the truth is they won because they campaigned hard on the issues Scottsdale residents care about most – stopping overdevelopment, public safety, water security and fiscal responsibility. And they were on the right side of all of those issues while their opponent was on the wrong side of them.
First among these issues is stopping overdevelopment. Overdevelopment has taken a heavy toll on Scottsdale’s special character and high quality of life. Clogged roads, blocked views, higher taxes, overburdened infrastructure, and now threats to our water supply have been the legacy of the overdevelopment previous City Council majorities have approved. And there is plenty of evidence proving residents want overdevelopment stopped.
In this election the poster child for overdevelopment was the Axon apartment project. From the very beginning Barry and Michelle not only opposed this awful project, but they also actively worked to defeat it! Candidate Zubia, on the other hand, became one of Axon’s biggest boosters:
- He took a $5,000 campaign contribution from an Axon executive just days after he proclaimed there was no money from Axon in his campaign war chest. He also took an $8,000 contribution from the REALTORS of Arizona PAC.
- He continued not only to support but to applaud the Axon apartment approval which, among other outrages, waived Axon’s water requirements—enough for 12,000 single family homes—which will leave less water for every other Scottsdale resident.
- He literally blamed Scottsdale citizens for, in his words, forcing Axon to go to the legislature to negate the citizens’ legal petition to put this development on the ballot! Clearly, he thought Axon’s interests were more important than the interests of Scottsdale residents!
- His major supporters consisted mostly of former Councilmembers (Milhaven, Manross, Janik, Drake, Campana and many more) who between them had approved literally thousands of new apartments!
During the campaign Zubia realized his stance as a proponent of massive overdevelopment would not get him elected in 2026. So, he made a political U-turn and started to claim he opposed more development in Scottsdale. But by then he had zero credibility as an opponent of overdevelopment.
Graham and Ugenti-Rita also defeated Zubia on the issue of water. In the primary Councilwoman Whitehead successfully gaslighted many voters into believing Scottsdale was on the brink of a water catastrophe and that our only hope of surviving was to accept her expensive and unproven plan to recycle sewer water into our drinking water supply. Seeing this tactic worked for Whitehead, Zubia jumped on board claiming that only electing him would protect Scottsdale’s water future. Unfortunately for candidate Zubia and his campaign Scottsdale’s Water Director recently gave a presentation to the City Council that our water department has a secure, diversified portfolio of water sources and proven options already underway — conservation, banking, system connections, and targeted acquisitions. Turns out candidate Zubi’s claims regarding our water supply were nothing more than election-season fearmongering and spin! The truth is Zubia and his development-loving buddies are the real threat to Scottsdale’s water security.
Bottom line; Graham and Ugenti-Rita were elected by campaigning on the local, non-partisan quality of life issues Scottsdale citizens care about most. That is the key to success in Scottsdale politics!
Councilwoman Kathy Littlefield
Former Councilman Bob Littlefield
Discover more from Arizona Progress Gazette
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

