In years past “ambulance chasers” was a derogatory description that could find its way to certain lawyers or law firms. Here in the Phoenix area the term was often associated with the Goldberg & Osborns of the legal profession. But we appear to have a new gold medalist: The Frutkin Law Firm.
In the great new age of social media there’s no need for the Frutkins of the world to actually go chase the wounded in ambulances and pass out cards at the hospital. Instead, they can just monitor headlines and prey on the gullible, as it appears they are doing with those interested in violating private property rights and “saving” the former Chinese Cultural Center near Sky Harbor Airport.
Look at this GoFundMe campaign they are promoting. https://www.gofundme.com/save-the-chinese-cultural-center. Basically, it’s a beg for up to $300,000 in legal fees for quixotic, long-shot claims that were bounced out of court earlier this month. What’s even sadder than the legal effort is the amount of money raised to date, just over $4,1000.
But perhaps that’s a good thing so it prevents other legal voyeurs from doing likewise. And with behavior like this it makes all the more clear why such a law firm sought to change its name earlier this year from the last name of the principals to something called Radix. That’s a technique tobacco companies and pay day lenders have used. How appropriate as we get closer to Halloween. A law firm and its losing ways that is all trick and no treat for the Chinese community, or for the state’s clear property rights laws.Read more
Once upon a time people named Pettycrew, Carla, Korte, Decabooter, Rau, Drinkwater, Manross, Campana and others sat around a Scottsdale table. They had the audacity to not only dream of a McDowell Sonoran Preserve, but to make it happen.
Today, it stands as the community’s greatest accomplishment.
Paradise Valley is blessed to have similar landscapes. They, like Scottsdale’s, define its very essence. And as in Scottsdale the threat of too much development up high is causing certain Paradise Valley leaders to look more seriously at preserving more.
That’s why we applaud the action of Paradise Valley Town Councilwoman Julie Pace, cited for her leadership on the issue, among others, in this recent Paradise Valley Independent article. http://paradisevalleyindependent.com/news/town-council-has-eyes-for-hillside-preservation-in-paradise-valley/
But as noble as we think these steps we don’t think they go far enough. Reinvigoration of the Mummy Mountain Preserve Trust is a fine thing but it is an entity that relies on private donations to increase the community’s open space. Past is prologue and this, ultimately, would be more pissing in the wind.
What’s called for is a town survey of all properties that might be included in preserve efforts. There may be dozens and they may be pricey. But the total costs for maximum preservation should be understood. From there it can be determined how much of a sales tax increase is necessary, and for how long, to pay to acquire such lots.
No one should be scared of such a discussion because ultimately the question of if and how to fund such an endeavor would be left to voters, as occurred in Scottsdale. And Telluride. And Phoenix. And countless other communities around the state and country that said open space and views were worth the price.
It’s well past time for Arizona’s toniest town to engage this debate. After all, it does welcome all visitors to the community with impressive monument signage showcasing mountaintops, not roof tops.
Kudos to one of the new kids on the PV block for getting this important conversation underway. Now it’s time to quicken the pace.Read more
by Desert EDGE Advocates
The Honorable Paul Messinger
The Seven Wonders of this Great Community
The accomplishments that separate Scottsdale from other Valley cities:
1. Modifying the Indian Bend Wash into a very successful flood control project and great open space and parks project
2. Scottsdale putting its electric utilities underground and requiring fire sprinkler systems in all buildings built shortly after its beginning
3. Our master planning of our community parks, open space and elimination of all billboards
4. WestWorld, with its major world-class and diverse events
5. Scottsdale’s performing arts center, contemporary art museum and Civic Center Mall
6. Western Spirit: Scottsdale’s Museum of the West – a world destination from the start
7. And our biggest City project, the McDowell Sonoran Preserve and “desert discovery center” (now known as The Desert EDGE). . .coming soon!
Every project took years to do, as well as great amounts of our community treasure and effort. The McDowell Sonoran Preserve was already voted on by Scottsdale’s citizenry in the early 1990s – just lacking the construction of its desert discovery center – The Desert EDGE.
Ninety percent of the citizens who voted for the Preserve nearly 25 years ago – and who have been paying for it ever since – cannot access it. Only our City’s youth and those who are physically strong – those who hike, ride mountain bikes or who are able to ride the trails on horseback, are able to actually use the Preserve.
The Desert EDGE will serve the majority of Scottsdale’s population socially and educationally, as well as to tell our visitors about our type of desert. Many local families, as well, know very little about this country, which we call “home.”
Paul & Cora Messinger
Lois Drinkwater Thompson
Move Forward with The Desert EDGE
I would ask the mayor and city council proceed with the Desert EDGE project and not refer it for a public vote. My brother, Herb Drinkwater, would never have spent $500,000 on a vote when the project had already been approved. A small group of loud naysayers have tried to derail this project.
They have attacked any supporters including me when I tried to correct their facts. And, they don’t give the facts. They still have posted old information from a project from eight years ago. If these angry people want a vote, they can get public signatures for a referendum. That is how our system works.
Not trying to loudly force the Council into putting it on the ballot for them. The council needs to realize that we are a “silent majority” and want this benefit for the city of Scottsdale.
I know the Desert EDGE can be approved by the council and I would urge them to do so. It would be an incredible world class amenity for the city and would bring global attention to Scottsdale’s long-standing reputation for leadership in environmental sensitivity, sustainability and preservation. Desert EDGE is critical to the success of education in the McDowell Sonoran Preserve. And, I say that as a former teacher and coach for over 34 years in the public school district.
Our immediate family has over 100 years of public education in Scottsdale and this would be a value to our school kids and teachers. A public vote is not required and a huge waste of my tax dollars.Read more
We don’t typically commend things Littlefield. After all it’s been some 330 days sense Classless Bob Littlefield has failed to call and congratulate Scottsdale Mayor Jim Lane on the latter’s landslide win last November. Humility following political humiliation might have even been cathartic.
But the sins of the husband should not flow to Bob’s wife Kathy, a Scottsdale City Councilmember.
This past week she launched an effective broadside against the Desert Discovery Center, properly pushing it even further to the edge. According to Littlefield’s guest column that ran in the Scottsdale Independent (here is a link) she even spent her own money to commission a public opinion survey on the project. The results were in line with other private polling that’s been done. Bottom line: The Desert Discovery Center is a dead project walking. Interestingly, Littlefield didn’t query whether citizens feel there should be a public vote on the project, a notion that is shared by some 90% of the electorate.
Proponents of the Desert Discovery Center when not ignoring public sentiment resort to their best James Madison suggesting that the rulers of the Scottsdale’s republic know best, and a public vote such a nuisance as to be unnecessary.
But isn’t a public vote how the spectacular McDowell Sonoran Preserve came to be in the first place? Wasn’t its substantial margin of victory critical to solidifying the many difficult steps that were needed to make the vision a reality? Indeed. And a public vote should and must be utilized now as project proponents want to divert tens of millions of dollars from preserve maintenance and land acquisition to the Duplicative Desert (Botanical) Center.Read more
*According to The Phoenix Business Journal U.S. Senator John McCain is working on a plan with Valley leaders to extend the Salt River’s “Rio Salado” experience and environment from Tempe to the West Valley. If true and if successful it sure would be a lasting legacy to Arizona, and the man.
*Uncertainty reigns in the lead-up to Scottsdale City Council elections. While incumbent Linda Milhaven looks like a sure thing to run again, undecided and close to the vest mark the current decision making status of incumbents Kathy Littlefield and David Smith as well as potential challengers Jason Alexander and Bill Crawford.
*Lancing a boil. One of Paradise Valley’s most vexing development parcels, the “Town Triangle” located just off Scottsdale Road got the green light this week from the Planning Commission, a testament to creative planning by renowned local developers Geoffrey Edmunds and Rod Cullum.
*That Daniel Valenzuela, a humble firefighter, has evolved into the frontrunner in the Phoenix Mayor’s race is remarkable.
*It’s one thing to support Scottsdale’s Desert Discovery Center but it’s quite another to oppose a public vote on it, something about 90% of the electorate relays to pollsters they want.
*Marco Rubio is back in town on Monday, supporting a number of candidates including Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich. A long shot who became a big shot after his upset win(s) in 2014 Brnovich has governed with notable sobriety, competence and judgment. And it’s nice to see Rubio stepping up to help someone who helped him in 2016 as his presidential campaign chairman in Arizona.
Phoenix Rising is the name of the Valley’s dynamic new soccer team with major league ambitions. But there’s another rising of note, taking place in Glendale.
Just a few short years ago the city was lying prone, left for dead, on the verge of declaring bankruptcy. Fast forward to just the past few months.
IKEA is coming. So is Top Golf and Drive Shack. Then there’s the city’s biggest master-planned community since Arrowhead Ranch about to become a reality nearby. Approved in June by Mayor Jerry Weiers and a majority of the city council Stonehaven by Pulte Homes and the John F. Long Company promises more bodies for the businesses.
Finally, there was a noteworthy Glendale Star story last month describing how AEG, Gila River Arena’s new operator, has nearly tripled revenues since taking over the from Arizona Coyotes and the dreary days of the LeBlanc regime.
These indeed are better times for the city that sets the pace in the West Valley. The Camelback Ranch spring training complex remains and albatross but these days Glendale is moving once again to that best possible future former Mayor Elaine Scruggs used to wax so eloquent about.Read more
*After the Troon North HOA’s shellacking of a Motel 6 looking, timeshare-like development at its entrance along comes a nursing home proposal for the old Sassi restaurant site near Pinnacle Peak. Good luck with that. Apparently the initial community meeting was a blood bath.
*Keep an eye on Scottsdale Planning Commissioner Christian Serena as a potential city council candidate in 2018, or more likely 2020
*The Scottsdale Firefighter’s Association dinner has become an “it” political event. Sunday night proved no exception as honored guests included Mountainside Fitness CEO Tom Hatten, Arizona Coyotes’ legend (and Scottsdale resident) Shane Doan and Linda Pauling, the mother that sparked Make-A-Wish. But the best sightof all? A row of 5 seats at the Scottsdale Charros table. Scottsdale Area Chamber CEO Mark Hiegel sat in the middle separating Councilwoman Linda Milhaven and former Scottsdale Councilman Dennis Robbins from Councilwoman Kathy Littlefield and former Councilman Bob Littlefield who lost huge to Mayor Jim Lane in 2016. Must have been awkward, but not quite as much as the congregation of NODDC crusader Jason Alexander, Councilwoman Virginia Korte and Barrett-Jackson CEO Craig Jackson at a recent Scottsdale Tourism Development Commission meeting.
*If you haven’t yet read today’s Arizona Republic editorial supporting a public vote on the Desert Discovery Center On Razor’s Edge check it out.Read more
In advance of the Iraq War and facing profound domestic opposition, UK Prime Minister Tony Blair shied away from no one, including his fiercest critic in the media. He stood his ground and defended his position. Whether one agreed with it at the time it showed confidence, command and leadership.
We feel the same way about Scottsdale City Councilwoman Linda Milhaven. While we may disagree with her on support for the Desert Discovery Center, she is Tony Blair on a local level.
Milhaven is pro-business, pro-arts, pro-downtown and pro-preservation. Responsive to all, she seems to relish engagement on the toughest issues. In many ways she is the constitution of what makes Scottsdale great, and where the majority of citizens are, as reflected in the 2016 mayoral election. And Milhaven has a resume to match. Banker. Former head of the Scottsdale Cultural Council. Public service.
A recent Scottsdale Republic article revealed her as the only certain incumbent or potential challenger to run. That’s great news for Scottsdale. Our jury is still out when it comes to the others (Councilman David Smith, Counwilwoman Kathy Littlefield and NO DDC chieftain Jason Alexander). It’s not if Mayor Jim Lane ally Bill Crawford decides to run in 2018, or 2020.
But for now it’s not too early to celebrate, and endorse a class, impressive act named Linda Milhaven.Read more
During the 2006 election season many city officials throughout Arizona, including Phoenix, campaigned against Proposition 207. They warned many things why the “Private Property Rights Protection Act” should be defeated. Chief among them were that providing too much individual protection for homeowners and commercial property owners would hamstring municipal redevelopment and historic preservation efforts. Voters rejected such arguments and Proposition 207 passed with a sizable 65% of the vote.
This is an important history lesson as some want to suspend the law and dictate what the new owner of the twenty-year old Chinese Cultural Center near 44th and Van Buren can do with their property.
But not all.
As a mob rained down on Phoenix City Hall and demanded Mayor Greg Stanton and his fellow politicians lay fetal rather than display fidelity to state law, the city’s Planning Director Alan Stephenson took a more courageous tact, no matter how uncomfortable and inconvenient.
Having laid out in his staff report why Phoenix could not and should not circumvent clear private property rights embedded in Proposition 207, Stephenson’s knees did not get weak even when confronted by a full house of angry Chinese Americans. He didn’t win an award for being the most popular that day but his sobriety on the subject was necessary to avoid groupthink.
Stephenson understood that it would be a nice thing to keep a Chinese Cultural Center even if the Chinese owner and developer of the property abandoned it, and sold it, in 2016. But he also understood that someone needed to be the big boy in the room as politicians kowtowed.
After all, Phoenix has never designated a site for historic preservation against the property owner’s wishes, not even for the David Wright House in Arcadia. It’s never designated a site as such that’s only twenty years old either. And when it comes to Proposition 207’s clear mandate on such things you can work to change it, but you can’t ignore it until then.
This leads us to a few other principles and principals.
When Rawhide left, and left a hole in Scottsdale’s western heritage after a duration similar to the Chinese Cultural Center, residents understood it to be unfortunate but not worthy of upending the rule of law to harm the property owner.
When Monti’s La Casa Vieja in Tempe said that’s a wrap the 100-year old home of Carl Hayden was left untouched, but not even the 50-year old stuff that surrounded it.
When dissidents started this quixotic quest they asked for the garden along 44th Street to be “saved,” which it is now being, along with the preservation of a number of other items both on and off-site, even though the new property owner doesn’t have to. Now that’s not enough.
When people say that other elements besides the garden are irreplaceable are they sure some, if not all of them can’t be procured today on Alibaba.com?
When the Phoenix City Council votes to “study” the matter, a precursor to a Proposition 207 violation, and then accepts private funds from a special interest that is driving the outcome of the study how is that showing integrity the new owner purportedly lacks?
When opposition is being led by a person whose last claim to fame was having her office raided by the FBI for purported development fraud we ask ourselves if the real motivation here is not preservation of a Cultural Center but to use politics to bully an acquisition in order to collect more fees as was controversially done for the Phoenix Mart project in Casa Grande?Read more
Whether you like or dislike Scottsdale Mayor Jim Lane, and judging from his landslide re-election win in 2016 a lot of people do, it’s hard not to admire the way he leads the city with decency, integrity and class.
The same can’t always be said of the respective camps vying over the fate of the Desert Discovery Center (DDC) in Scottsdale.
We are no fans of the project as we have explained repeatedly. But we are also no fans of some of the stooges like Mark Stuart who lead the effort. While we admire the passion of opponents, among the best grassroots opposition groups anywhere in recent memory, they can certainly go too far. We have written about such times in the past but it bears repeating now as some in the movement attack terrific Scottsdale businesses like the Fairmont Princess because they happen to be supporters of the Desert Discovery Center. The property is one of the city’s finest hotels, adding to cache and coffers. We do not like their position on the DDC but we readily spend money there anyways. Long after the DDC is dead and gone the Fairmont Princess will still be doing good for Scottsdale, as it was doing before the debate started. DDC opponents need not snatch defeat from the jaws of victory with such obnoxious tactics.Read more